McCarthy will expose his members to hard votes, killing the House NDAA and increasing the Senate NDAA’s Chances
Perano, Daily Beast, 7-14-23
[Ursula, 7-14-2023, Daily Beast "Kevin McCarthy Cedes Speakership to the Far Right Once Again,", , Accessed 7/14/23, S.A.M]
Rep. Nancy Mace (R-SC), who has been pushing her party to find a “middle ground” on abortion, told reporters on Thursday that she was aghast at the abortion amendment.
“I have strong misgivings about targeting women in the military,” she said. “What message does that send to women who are willing to take a bullet for our country?”
And yet, just hours later in the day, Mace voted in favor of the abortion amendment. She later told reporters “the military doesn’t reimburse travel for elective procedures, as a general policy rule.” She said the amendment preserved that precedent.
(As one reporter pointed out to Mace, elective procedures are not broadly illegal in states, and therefore don’t often require travel.)
But Mace went on, at one point repeating her earlier question on what House Republicans have done for women this year—if anything.
“It’s not gonna pass the Senate anyway. It doesn’t matter. It’s not getting through in the final NDAA,” Mace said. When another reporter pointed out the abortion amendment could sink the bill, Mace responded, “Again, Democrats are smarter than that. Everybody knows that amendment will not stay when it goes to the Senate.”
The amendment might not even stay in the House bill. If McCarthy can’t get sufficient support for NDAA final passage on Friday—which is when the House is supposed to take its final vote—the Speaker may eventually try to strip the abortion amendment in a concession to Democrats.
Such a move would almost certainly cost McCarthy GOP votes, and could damage his standing with his own conference, but it would likely attract more Democratic votes than whatever he loses on his side.
The other option—perhaps the likeliest one—is that Republicans stick together and pass the defense bill on essentially a party-line vote. It would mean exposing his members to these tough votes, and almost all of them going on the record in support of an $886 billion defense budget, which could be yet another tough thing to explain to voters.