Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

New spending requires budget offsets – Farm Bill cuts risk derailing compromise due to heightened expectations

Coppess, University of Illinois Agricultural & Consumer Economics professor, 6-15-23

[Jonathan, 6-15-23, Farm Doc Daily Illinois, “Farm Bill 2023: Trying To Reason With Expectations For Farm Policy”, , accessed 7-3-23, EH]

The challenges presented by relatively higher crop prices are not unusual for farm bill reauthorizations, most notably in the efforts for the 1973, 1996, and 2014 Farm Bills. For 2023’s debate, however, the challenges are magnified by elevated expectations created by payment experiences since 2018. As indicated in Figure 2, farmers have received record levels of payments in recent years particularly from ad hoc and supplemental assistance programs not authorized in a farm bill. These ad hoc and supplemental payments have extended assistance to a much more extensive population of farmers than do traditional farm payment programs, including payments to livestock and specialty crop producers. Figure 4 provides an example, illustrating a categorical breakdown of the total payments from MFP 2019, CFAP 1 and CFAP 2 as reported by USDA (USDA, farmers.gov: ; ; ). In total, these three programs have paid more than $45.7 billion to farmers.

Managing expectations in a farm bill debate could come from the payment experiences of livestock and specialty crop farmers who do not ordinarily receive direct payments in farm bill programs. An additional challenge from Figure 4 could be increased expectations for payments from those farmers who ordinarily receive farm program payments but have received much more in these ad hoc and supplemental programs. Figure 5 takes the MFP 2019, CFAP 1 and CFAP 2 payments for just the program crops and charts them by state. Figure 5 also adds the total ARC and PLC payments for 2018 to 2021 by state as reported by USDA-ERS (USDA-ERS, Farm Income and Wealth Statistics, ). Farmers of these program crops received a total of $14.3 billion in 2018 through 2021 from ARC and PLC, with an additional $27.6 billion from MFP 2019, CFAP 1, and CFAP 2 payments. Farmers of these crops in Texas received the most in total, followed by those in Iowa, Illinois and Kansas.

Concluding Thoughts

Trying to reason with and manage expectations is a substantial challenge for any farm bill reauthorization. In 2023, that challenge could be greatly magnified if the ad hoc and supplemental payments in recent years have set expectations for payments at unreasonably and unachievably high levels; adding further complications, such expectations are coinciding with a time of high prices and incomes. Recall that in a farm bill reauthorization effort, the CBO baseline is controlling—it is the total amount of funding available to the committees and it is against the ten-year baseline that CBO scores any changes. The ad hoc and supplemental payments, however, are not included in the CBO baseline for a farm bill. Under budget rules, moreover, any increases in spending for a program or title is scored over 10 years, all of which must be offset by decreases from other programs or titles; in other words, a $1 billion change in program or policy could score $10 billion and require a large offset. This creates a zero-sum political dynamic that complicates the coalition building and maintenance necessary to pass a bill in Congress. For Title I farm program payments, any changes to increase payments would need to be offset by decreases within the title or from other titles in the bill. The politics for achieving offsets is exceedingly difficult and the search for offsets can make adversaries or enemies out of allies and coalition partners. The effort to reauthorize the Farm Bill in 2023 largely escaped unscathed from the debt limit negotiations, but the path ahead could become politically perilous in its own right with expectations out of alignment with budget and political realities.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.