Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The aff is not politically feasible – the plan would trigger massive controversy

Morrison, Competitive Enterprise Institute senior fellow, 21

[Richard, 7/3/2021, Competitive Enterprise Institute, “The Case Against a Universal Basic Income”, , accessed 7/3/2023, eo]

The vast majority of programs target specific groups — children, the disabled and the elderly — that have the greatest need. Under the current system, shame felt by an able-bodied adult capable of working is a feature, not a bug.

That common sense approach to work and responsibility poses a big obstacle for any UBI proposal. Despite the UBI’s approval ratings when Americans are asked about it, actual legislation to implement it would be highly controversial. In the 1970s, presidents Richard Nixon and Jimmy Carter — who had famously divergent political views — both endorsed UBI proposals that went down to defeat when the public was confronted with the details.

Many recent UBI proposals have called for a new benefit to replace much, if not all, existing social welfare spending. This radical simplification, often called a “grand bargain,” would theoretically ally conservatives, who want to reform the system’s cost and complexity, with progressives, who want to avoid anyone “falling through the cracks” of the many different current programs. But anyone who thinks that such a bargain is likely has spent too much time in political theory seminars and not enough time on Capitol Hill.

In order for such a bipartisan effort to work, policymakers would have to wipe enough current spending off the books to finance a universal benefit. That means that many programs that anti-poverty activists currently cherish would be permanently eliminated.

Say goodbye to Temporary Assistance for Needy Families, the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (“food stamps”) and Supplemental Security Income for people with a disability.

The version advanced by conservative policy analyst Charles Murray, a frequently cited advocate, would abolish all of Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid as well.

There are plenty of reasonable — even radical — arguments for reforming current welfare spending, but any plan to do so must reckon with reality. A plan that would eliminate current anti-poverty programs and replace them with a single UBI is simply not politically feasible.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.