Social Security reform will trigger a tough debate about raising taxes or reducing benefits
Biggs, American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research Senior Fellow, 23
[Andrew, 6/22/23, American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research, “Bill Cassidy’s Well Intentioned But Misguided Social Security Reform,” Accessed 7/3/2023, J.D.]
Senator Bill Cassidy (R., Louis.) has been making the media rounds promoting his idea for a bipartisan Social Security reform plan, including a recent article in National Review Online. I admire Cassidy’s efforts, even more so when the leaders of both political parties have failed to show the initiative that Social Security reform warrants. If every Senator were like Cassidy, Social Security’s multi-trillion dollar shortfall would have been addressed rather than left to fester for decades. And yet, Cassidy’s core idea — the federal government borrowing $1.5 trillion to invest in the stock market, with the proceeds directed to Social Security — isn’t a very good one. It’s effectively a tax increase in disguise, and one that comes with considerable risk and instability to federal government finances.
Policymakers have known for over three decades that Social Security needs reform, due to rising longevity that increases the beneficiary rolls and low birth rates that reduce the number of workers whose taxes support the program. The choices also are well-known: Revenues flowing into the program must increase or benefits must be reduced. Every reform option — from increasing the $160,000 ceiling on wages subject to taxes or raising the payroll tax rate to making the retirement age higher or reducing Cost of Living Adjustments — ultimately comes down to increasing revenues or reducing benefits.
The problem, of course, is that politicians don’t like either option. And so, they have delayed a tough decision, thus making the fix that must someday come even more difficult for Americans.
To his credit, Cassidy has come up with a plan. Unfortunately, though, it is designed to appeal to politicians who otherwise don’t want to make tough decisions, who neither want to raise taxes nor cut benefits.