Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Bidenomics is supporting the Red States more than the Blue States

Noah, New Republic, 7-12-23

[Timothy, 7-12-2023, New Republic, "You’ll Be Very Surprised Who’s Benefiting Most From Bidenomics," , Accessed 7/15/23, S.A.M]

A paradox of Bidenomics is that it’s been more beneficial to red (predominantly Republican) states than to blue (predominantly Democratic) ones. This might perhaps help explain why Biden’s approval rating among Democrats has fallen to 78 percent, but it flatly contradicts Biden’s downward approval rating among Republicans to 5 percent.

We take for our text a June 30 news release from the Commerce Department’s Bureau of Economic Analysis tracking growth in personal income from January through March 2023. The correlation is uncanny between states where incomes are rising fastest and states that absolutely revile Joe Biden.

In North Dakota, which Biden lost to Trump by 34 points, and where Biden’s net approval rating was negative 46 percent in March, according to a Morning Consult compilation, personal income during the first quarter of 2023 rose 11 percent over the previous year.

In Nebraska, which Biden lost by 20 points, and where Biden’s net approval rating in March was negative 36 percent, personal income rose 11.1 percent.

In Montana, which Biden lost by 16 points, and where Biden’s net approval was negative 21 percent, personal income rose 8.3 percent.

In South Carolina, which Biden lost by 12 points, and where Biden’s net approval was negative 23 percent, personal income rose 6.8 percent.

All these increases in personal income exceeded the national average, which was 5.1 percent. In North Dakota and Nebraska, personal income growth was more than twice the national average. Hey red states, Biden might justifiably think. You’re welcome!

The blue states were not so fortunate.

California? Biden won the Golden State by 30 points, and his net approval rating there was 11 percent, his highest in the country. As Biden would say, God love ’em. But personal income was up only 0.7 percent.

New York? Biden won the Empire State by 23 points, his net approval there was 3 points, and personal income grew 3.2 percent.

Maryland? Biden won it by 34 points, his net approval there was 8 percent, and personal income grew 5 percent, a whisker below the national average.

Not every state conformed to this pattern. Maine, Michigan, and Oregon all went for Biden in 2020, and in all three, personal income grew well in excess of the national average. But these states are not outliers in every respect. In all three, Biden’s approval numbers were under water.

What explains this bizarre circumstance? The Wall Street Journal’s editorial page, which lacks my refined palate for paradox, resolves the contradiction by pretending there is none. The blue states, it says,

boast high taxes and a high cost of living, which along with Covid lockdowns spurred increased out-migration during the pandemic…. States with higher earnings growth … tend to have lower tax rates as well as fast-growing populations…. More Americans are moving to states where wages are growing faster and their earnings go further.

This doesn’t stand up to scrutiny. People don’t migrate that much at all anymore compared to previous eras; as I’ve written elsewhere, the “Go West, Young Man” spirit of following where opportunity leads has greatly diminished, to the severe detriment of the national economy. This has occurred even as disparities between levels of state taxation have increased. Michael Mazerov, a senior fellow at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, observed in January that in 1990 the combined state and local tax burden in the 10 highest-tax states (nearly all blue) was 69 percent higher than in states without income taxes (nearly all red). By 2020 it was 85 percent higher. Yet interstate migration went down, not up; since 2010 it’s been 1.5 percent, or half of what it was in earlier decades.

Why do people migrate less? Opinions differ. Some say it’s because families with two working parents are more reliant on grandparents for child care than they used to be. Some (I’m in this camp) say it’s because economic opportunity is now stratified by educational attainment, rendering a move to, say, San Francisco more plausible for a computer programmer with a graduate degree than for a data-entry clerk with an associate’s degree. The data clerk might boost his wage, but not sufficiently to cover the higher cost of living. Indeed, to the extent that economic migration persists, it’s often not toward economic opportunity but away from it, because places with less economic opportunity have cheaper housing. Some studies argue that state tax policies influence migration significantly, especially since the state and local tax deduction for federal income tax was eliminated in 2017. But the authors of these studies seldom consider that for the average worker, housing weighs much more heavily than a state income tax in any cost-of-living calculation.

All right, then. We’ve established that the red states’ larger growth in personal income isn’t likely explained by state governance. And while Bidenomics helps account for the general prosperity enlivening the national economy, I see no evidence that the president is deliberately targeting economic stimulus to people who despise him. So what’s happening?

I think it relates to something I wrote about earlier this week: the rapid increase in wages that occurred during the labor shortage that followed Covid’s peak, a period known as the Great Resignation. (It’s over now.) This wage increase was heavily tilted toward low-wage workers. It was so large that economists David Autor of MIT and Arindrajit Dube of the University of Massachusetts, along with Annie McGrew, a graduate student in economics at UMass, reported in March that it reversed one-quarter of a four-decade runup in wage inequality between the bottom 10 percent in the income distribution and the top 10 percent.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.