Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

SNAP reforms key with Conservatives

Rachidi, Senior Fellow and Rowe Scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, 06-23-23

[Angela, 6-23-2023, American Enterprise Institute - AEI, "SNAP Can Improve Nutrition, Help Farmers, and Support the Environment," https://www.aei.org/op-eds/snap-can-improve-nutrition-help-farmers-and-support-the-environment/?mkt_tok=NDc1LVBCUS05NzEAAAGMlh6KxtGn-Mh8fLw4IAcH5rgI61_0yo5XJ8d2CTwNwPh6vNHahYIt14RvPWWvjsCfbIcfAMHfioDgkaWXfihwiRCkilDJ4iVC3nccMB9Yjaw8, Accessed 7-12-23, S.A.M]

In contrast, SNAP provides more than $100 billion in food benefits to low-income families each year and covers 40 million people, approximately 12% of the US population. Yet, the program has no nutritional standards and participants spend a sizeable share of benefits (at least 25%) on unhealthy foods such as sugary beverages, frozen prepared foods, prepared desserts and candy.

One way to increase demand for healthy foods is to transform how SNAP administers benefits. By restricting the use of SNAP benefits to conform with the Dietary Guidelines for Americans (DGAs), millions of Americans will experience improved diets. Because SNAP covers a sizeable share of the population, increased demand for healthy foods among program participants could influence the purchases of those higher up the income scale as well.

Currently, the USDA determines the maximum SNAP benefit for each household size using the “Thrifty Food Plan,” defined as the estimated cost of “a nutritious, practical, cost-effective diet prepared at home.” The Thrifty Food Plan balances the DGAs with constraints on time and convenience, leading the Plan to incorporate calorie-dense processed foods. Furthermore, even though the Thrifty Food Plan is supposed to represent a nutritious diet, there is no requirement that SNAP participants use their benefits to purchase those foods.

Under my plan, researchers would still estimate the cost of a “Thrifty Food Plan” (see this primer on the Thrifty Food Plan) to set SNAP benefit levels, but the only constraint would be the DGAs. SNAP benefits would be divided into two categories – “green” benefits to be used only for DGAs recommended foods, including minimally processed vegetables, fruits, grains, proteins, oils and unsweetened dairy. SNAP participants could use “red” benefits for anything else. Research would inform the proper distribution of benefits between the two groups. If, for example, 75% of monthly SNAP benefits were allocated for “green” foods, then 75% of each households benefits would be restricted to purchasing foods that fit into that category.

While classifying every food into categories may sound overly complicated, SNAP could rely on the NOVA food classification system to determine what constitutes a “green” food versus a “red” food. And the new system could utilize digital currency and store level technology to track food purchases. Many states already use ConnectEBT, which allows SNAP participants to monitor benefit use through a mobile app. Linking this type of mobile application to SNAP retailer Point-of-Sale (POS) systems would allow SNAP participants to monitor their green and red purchases and track the foods they purchase over time.

Additionally, SNAP retailers would be encouraged to market their products according to whether they are SNAP-eligible or not, which essentially translates into a food that the DGAs recommends versus one that the DGAs recommends limiting. Retailers could even place green and red stickers on SNAP-eligible foods, which could also influence other consumers. Finally, the USDA could also simplify the process for becoming a SNAP-retailer for producers of “green” foods, including local farming cooperatives, farmer’s markets, and other fresh produce, meat, and dairy farms.

Moving to this type of SNAP system would be widely unpopular among processed food and sugary beverage companies, but over time it could shift their incentives toward more healthy food production that benefits our health, the environment and our farmers.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.