Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

UBI decreases the workforce, and slows economic growth and risks spiraling inflation

Mitchell, University of Newcastle Centre of Full Employment and Equity Director and Economics Professor, 17

[William, 5/31/17, William, Professor in Economics and Director of the Centre of Full Employment and Equity (CofFEE), at the University of Newcastle,“A Basic Income Guarantee does not reduce poverty,” https://billmitchell.org/blog/?p=36105, accessed 6/27/23, EP]

So there you have it. A BIG as is typically proposed is not a magic cure for poverty.

Under fiscal neutrality, the maximum sustainable BIG would be modest. Aggregate demand and employment impacts would be small, and even with some redistribution of working hours; high levels of labour underutilisation would persist.

Overall this strategy does not enhance the rights of the most disadvantaged, nor does it provide work for those who desire it.

It is obvious that persistent unemployment could easily be avoided by the introduction of the BIG if it was accompanied by a net government stimulus (deficit).

This recognises that at all times, given the spending and saving decisions of the non-government sector, the existing unemployment level is the choice of the currency-issuing government – in other words, mass unemployment means that the deficit is too small relative to non-government saving desires.

Without an appropriate fiscal stimulus, the basic income proposal would achieve full employment by persuading the unemployed to drop out of the labour force upon receipt of an income guarantee.

The economy would move towards full employment by stealth – pushing workers out of the labour force rather than providing work for them.

But the value of the currency would then fall given that nothing is provided in return for the government spending.

The resulting inflationary bias would invoke interest rate adjustments (given the current inflation-first approach adopted by central banks) that would constrain the economy from achieving sufficient growth to offer real employment options to all aspiring workers.

But then a further quandary emerges. The more generous BIG, would probably stimulate total spending such that there would be a shortage of labour at ‘full employment’, resulting from the artificial reduction of the full employment level of employment, which then compounds the inflationary pressure.

The alternative is that the excess demand for goods would be increasingly met via imports with consequential effects for the exchange rate and the domestic price level, which would accentuate the inflationary pressure.

Thus the introduction of a BIG policy is likely to be highly problematic with respect its capacity to deliver both sustained full employment and price stability.

[***NOTE – BIG = Basic Income Guarantee***]

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.