Thomas, University of York Philosophy professor, 20
[Thomas, University of York Philosophy professor, 6-4-20, Basic Income Studies, "Full Employment, Unconditional Basic Income and the Keynesian Critique of Rentier Capitalism," Vol. 15, Iss. 1, Pages 18-21 ProQuest, DOA - 6/24/23 – DD]
There is a specific, macro-economic concern about Van Parijs’s UBI that Minsky explicitly discusses – under his usual description of it as a “negative income tax”. His concern is that this policy is self-stultifying because of its effect on inflation: the purchasing power of the worst off is boosted, only then to be undermined. I think, in Rawlsian terms, we can describe it as one aspect of a conception of justice proving to be unstable – unable to reproduce itself over time.
I have already described Minsky’s general argument that tax and transfer schemes, absent an independent commitment to full employment, are of their nature inflationary. Those who produce are taxed and that income is moved to those who do not produce goods or services for consumption. This latter group spend a higher proportion of the transferred resources than those from whom it is transferred. Minsky believed that this inherently inflationary transfer was exacerbated by a UBI via its impact on labour market participation rates.
It is true that some people who are currently involuntarily unemployed would, if in receipt of an UBI, be drawn on to the labour market, namely, those currently caught up in benefits traps. But Minsky’s concern is that a significant number of those currently on the labour market will withdraw from it. As Minsky notes, many of the currently poor cannot attach much value to leisure as leisure activities are themselves costly. Not only would a person currently in poverty be even poorer if they reduced their market participation, the leisure would be inadequate compensation given their lack of resources that would allow them to enjoy it. Under a UBI, however, the incentive to introduce more leisure into the economy is accompanied with a financial incentive to make use of it. Those conditions together are likely to produce substantial exit from the labour market.
It follows that, at the macro-level, one the one hand, spending power is transferred to those more likely to make use of it. This is an attractive and deliberate upshot of a UBI. However, another macro-effect will be that fewer people will participate in the labour market, so that wages will have to be increased by employers to “bid up” the value of labour. Only this increased remuneration will attract those who could otherwise live on an UBI. As a result, employers will increase wages and push that cost through to prices. Minsky argued that the resulting inflationary increase will largely cancel out the value of a UBI to the worst off, making the policy (from a Rawlsian perspective) self-stultifying. Even those drawn on to the labour market by being freed from benefits traps will see their gains eroded by price inflation.
The real point of contrast is between the self-stultifying way in which an UBI leads to inflation that negates most of its good effects for the worst off, and a Rawlsian proposal widely to disperse capital, to ensure fair access to it, and to aim at reasonable equity in its distribution. You can either take SELR to be a policy contained already in this general description – if you include human capital as capital – or as complementary to it (Thomas, 2017, p. 403, fn. 41, 2020b). Rentier Capitalism 19.
The final issue to be addressed is the comparative one: if this paper claims that the policy of SELR achieves our egalitarian goals in a stable why, while an UBI does not, what guarantees that the former policy is not inflationary in the same way? Minsky believes that the transition from slack to tight full employment will be inflationary for a time, but:
The high wage worker and other affluent citizens have been subsidized, by way of low product prices, by the poor … tight full employment … will lead to cost-push inflation. (Minsky 2013a, p. 10).
[NOTE: Hyman Minsky, American economist]