Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

UBI will trigger price hikes risking high inflation and default

Wright, Augustana university economic historian & Przegalińska, Kozminski University Vice Rector, 22

[Robert E.; Aleksandra, 11-24-2022, “Debating Universal Basic Income Pros, Cons, and Alternatives”, University of Kentucky Library, pg.s 75-76, accessed 6-24-23, DS]

UBI might also increase the price level by simultaneously decreasing aggregate supply (due to lower incentives for net UBI donors to work) and increasing aggregate demand (due to higher incomes for many). That, in turn, could lead to pressure for a higher UBI and yet another round of higher prices and lower quantities produced (Sammeroff 2019, 31). Most countries, including the United States, are already in too much debt, so adding to it to fund UBI would either injure future generations or lead to high levels of inflation or even a hard default (Whaples 2015, 531).

Governments like that of the United States that issue a reserve currency may not face nominal budget constraints, as MMT advocates suggest, but they certainly face real budget constraints. Obviously, governments cannot redistribute more than economic entities (individuals, businesses, nonprofits) create. But far short of total confiscation, government redistribution, whether through direct or indirect taxes (like inflation), begins to decrease total economic output. A UBI that might seem afford- able at current levels of real output might quickly become impossible at lower levels of output induced by the implementation of UBI itself (Hendrickson 2021).

Some proponents of UBI claim that it can be implemented “by any political community: a community, a nation state, a part of a nation state, or a supra-national political unit” (Torry 2019, 83). It is difficult to see how that is possible, however, if any sort of MMT-like monetary policy will be used to fund the program. Only a currency union would be able to do so. If a UBI were to be funded by income or sales taxes, immigration would have to be limited, implying a national boundary, lest the jurisdiction be overrun by new arrivals eager to get something for nothing. A local UBI would have to be funded by a land tax like that proposed by Henry George and paid only to bona fide residents (McKenna 2019).

In short, UBI remains likely to be either socioeconomically inconsequential or destructive of economic growth. Once you factor in the administrative costs of tax collection, UBI will be another huge, popular, but pointless government program that enriches bureaucrats and politicians but nobody else.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.