Modern Monetary theory can’t account for the size of the plan – can’t stave off inflation
Phelan, Center of the American Experiment economic & Cobden Centre fellow, 19
[John, 3-29-19, Foundation for Economic Education, “Modern Monetary Theory: Debunking the Latest Incarnation of Government’s Magic Money Tree,” accessed 6-25-23, https://fee.org/articles/modern-monetary-theory-debunking-the-latest-incarnation-of-government-s-magic-money-tree/, ah]
There is no reason to believe that MMTers would be able to control inflation by the methods they suggest. Imagine a government operating on MMT lines. It prints money and spends it. Prices start to rise. The government raises taxes. This takes time—the passage of a tax bill as opposed to the relatively quick expedient of selling securities, which central banks do when they want to accomplish the same aim. Even if passed, this tax hike reduces output (y), exacerbating the problem.
Furthermore, to take money “out of the economy,” the government would have to run the sort of budget surplus MMT is predicated on freeing it from. The money raised by these high taxes—assuming they brought it in—could not be spent or redistributed. It has to be destroyed if the money supply (M) is to be reduced. As British inflation hit 26 percent in the 1970s, the government tried all manner of taxes to "sop up" "excess purchasing power," all without any notable success.
The Magic Money Tree
The current GDP of the US is about $20 trillion. Perhaps dumping in a couple of million here or there might have little impact on overall inflation.
But that is not what is being proposed. MMT advocates, such as Stephanie Kelton, argue that MMT offers a way to fund multi-trillion dollar programs such as a jobs guarantee and universal health care. The $32 trillion estimated cost of “Medicare for All” is the equivalent of 160 percent of current GDP. Modern Monetary Theory isn’t monetary policy so much as a way of escaping the inevitabilities of fiscal policy. It is beyond belief that the Federal Reserve could pump that much money into the economy without serious inflation.