Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Education and entrepreneurship would offset UBI inflation

Merrill & Neves, University of Minho politics professors, 21 [Catarina; Roberto, 2021, Basic Income Studies, “Unconditional Basic Income and State as an Employer of Last Resort: A Reply to Alan Thomas,” Vol 16, Issue 2, ProQuest, accessed: 6-24-23, DS]

One of Alan Thomas’ main concerns with UBI is its effect on inflation, and consequently its diminished impact in improving the material conditions for the worst-off. On the one hand, a UBI would transfer spending power to those who are most likely to make use of it, namely the worst-off in society. However, considering UBI’s assumed negative effect on work participation, wages will have to rise to attract those who could otherwise live on a UBI. Employers will increase wages and push that through rising prices. Therefore, this inflationary tendency will largely cancel out the value of a UBI to the worst-off. This effect is shared by many as a potential drawback of implementing a UBI.

There are two critical assumptions that determine a view of UBI as “canceling itself out” through inflation: the first is the assumption of labor withdrawal. If workers when granted a UBI exit the labor market (particularly low skilled ones), employers will be forced to increase wages to attract them, leading to the inflation effect mentioned above. A second assumption, intricately linked to the first, is that this withdrawal from the labor market will also be accompanied by a lack of investment in the productive capacity of citizens. Therefore, it will not be possible to increase the production of goods and services, which alongside labor withdrawal reinforces inflation. These two arguments are the reason why economists tend to believe SELR is superior to UBI on macroeconomic terms. In Thomas’ article we can read: “Minsky’s general argument [is] that tax and transfer schemes, absent an independent commitment to full employment, are of their nature inflationary. Those who produce are taxed and that income is moved to those who do not produce goods or services for consumption” (Thomas, 2020, p. 18). And he adds: “A UBI proposal popularizes demand by shifting resources towards those more likely to consume and away from “excessive” savings. But unlike SELR proposal, it fails to balance this out by investing in the productive capacity of individuals and firms” (Thomas, 2020, p. 19). Despite Thomas’ compelling account of the superior nature of SELR in countering inflationary pressures, it seems that his account of the potential impacts of a UBI is once again too hasty.

For one, as mentioned above, assuming UBI as leading to massive or even significant voluntary unemployment is pure speculation, and possibly an exag- geration considering existing evidence, not only of basic income experiments, but also of the role of employment in our societies. One could then argue about what would be the effect on wages, and hence on inflation, if people continue working.

A second point is the assumption that a UBI does not promote an investment in what Thomas calls the “productive capacity of individuals”, a crucial effect which is essential to counter inflationary turns, by rising productivity. However, there is no reason why a UBI, even in Van Parijs’ account, could not be complemented by existing (or other) programs for training and re-skilling. Van Parijs himself accounts for the benefits of programs of universal education (1995), and one can argue that he would share a similar view on adult learning programs, as long as they are not compulsory or tied to benefits, as they tend to be in existing social assistance schemes. Just as we tend to argue that investment in education and assistance on finding a job can be add-on policies to existing programs, or new ones like SELR, the same too could be implemented under a UBI scheme, as long as there is no associated obligation to the program. But even if for the sake of argu- ment we assume that a UBI would be a standalone policy, with no existing com- plements in terms of education or reskilling, there are still reasons to assume that a UBI can lead to an investment in “the productive capacity of individuals”. This reasoning is partly grounded on the results of basic income experiments, namely of some of the mentioned above. In the NIT experiments of the 60 and 70s, not only elementary school attendance increased (which can be seen as an investment in the individuals’ future productive capacity) but also, and most importantly for us, increases in adults going on to continued education were found (Widerquist, 2018, p. 50) and similar results were found in the experiments which took place in India and Namibia (Widerquist, 2018, p. 58). It was also in some of these poorer contexts that increase in entrepreneurial activities were found. Both an increase in educational attainment and entrepreneurship could lead to increased productivity of the goods and services supplied, hence offsetting possible inflationary pressures from the UBI.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.