The crisis of capitalism is inevitable and existential – at best the Aff delays a reckoning by suppressing class struggle and facilitating a new round of productive expansion that magnifies the risk
Robinson 22 [William, Distinguished professor of sociology, global studies and Latin American studies at UC Santa Barbara, Can Global Capitalism Endure? Epub]
Who can deny that global capitalism is in deep crisis? The global economy is mired in prolonged stagnation. Civil strife and social upheaval are tearing up political systems and, in some cases, leading to the collapse of states. The planetary ecosystem is breaking down. Millions are fleeing, displaced by climate change, transnational corporate land grabs, wars and political persecution. Hunger and disease are on the rise in many countries. The worldwide social fabric is in decay. The coronavirus contagion exposed governments, unable to cope with the fallout from the health emergency, as callous instruments of wealth and corruption. It is clear that the crisis is far more encompassing than its economic dimension alone; it is civilizational and existential. Yet the varied dimensions of this crisis of humanity have a common denominator: a socioeconomic system that relentlessly pursues private profit at all costs. The ruling groups appear clueless as to how to resolve the mounting crisis beyond ramping up a global police state to contain mounting unrest. This should come as no surprise. The political elites are beholden to the system of global capitalism that by its very nature places the endless accumulation of capital above all else. I have been writing about global capitalist crisis since the turn of the century from the perspective of my theory of global capitalism as a qualitatively new stage in the ongoing and open-ended evolution of world capitalism, characterized above all by the rise of truly transnational capital and the integration of every country into a globally-integrated productive, financial and service system. The work before you is an attempt to provide a concise summary of this theory and to further advance the analysis of the crisis originally laid out in my 2014 book, Global Capitalism and the Crisis of Humanity. My aim is to present a “big picture” snapshot in a shorter work and from the vantage point of global capitalism theory that takes into account some elements of global capitalism that have come further into focus in recent years, especially the ever-deeper financialization and digitalization of the global economy and society. As the title indicates, it is not clear how far into the future global capitalism can endure. A collapse of world civilization cannot be ruled out. To the contrary, the current course of events is leading to just that. Indeed, there are plenty of historical cases of societal collapse, with the distinction this time that what we understand as society is now irreversibly global. These days it is not particularly controversial to observe that capitalism has outlived whatever usefulness it may once have had. But just because the system is now archaic does not mean that it cannot hang on well into the future. The survival of global capitalism beyond the present crisis requires a substantial restructuring involving a measure of transnational regulation of the global economy and a redistribution of wealth downward. Even at that, though, a new period of economic reactivation and prosperity will not bring to an end the threat to our survival. For that, we must do away with a system whose drive to accumulate capital puts it at war with the mass of humanity and with nature. Only an ecosocialism can ultimately lift us from the threat. There is a vast literature on capitalist crisis and a rich history of debate among political economists, Marxists and non-Marxists alike. The theme of capitalist breakdown is recurrent in the social sciences, going back to the writings of Karl Marx in the second half of the nineteenth century and to the Polish-German socialist, Rosa Luxemburg, among others writing in the early twentieth century. The famed Austrian economist, Joseph Schumpeter, not a Marxist himself, titled one of the chapters in his celebrated 1942 study, Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy, “Can Capitalism Survive?” (He feared it could not).16 The January 1, 1975 issue of Time magazine, published in the midst of the previous major crisis of world capitalism blared the same question on its front cover.17 In that decade and subsequent to it, Marxists have reexamined the classical literature and hotly debated the nature of crises.18 In particular, Marxist economists debate whether capitalism can expand indefinitely, and if capitalist crises are caused by a fall in the rate of profit or by what is known as overproduction and underconsumption. I indicate my position with respect to this debate in the first section of this work. However, I am as much or more concerned here, as elsewhere, with a sociological study that takes up the social, political, ideological and cultural dimensions of the crisis as I am with its specifically economic dimension. The entire edifice of a global capitalism in crisis rests on an intensification of exploitation and of control over the exploited, which is what makes all economics political and a matter of social and class struggle. The 2008 Great Recession triggered a veritable tsunami of mass rebellion around the world not seen in decades. Far from letting up, worldwide protest escalated throughout the coronavirus contagion. As humanity descends into global civil war, the ruling groups have utilized the pandemic to launch all-out class warfare aimed at an exponential increase in profit-making opportunities and at ramping up the social control of restive masses.19 All systems are in a perpetual state of motion, transformation, and eventual demise, whether through collapse or supersession. The challenge for radical political economy of the type I aspire to here is to capture the motion of structural change and to identify possible trajectories and outcomes that are always contingent on politics and class struggle. And the challenge for radical intellectuals is to contribute through theory and analysis to exposing the contradictions of the prevailing system as input into the burning struggles of our day. As I attempt to take up these challenges, several caveats apply. Our explorations of the world are always an open-ended process of clarification and revision. The account here is necessarily a simplification, as are all synopses of complex reality that attempt to present a “big picture” in such broad brushstrokes. Moreover, I have set out to both analyze the present and to speculate as to what the future may hold. This is an exploratory work with some of its arguments tentative in nature. As such, conclusions are preliminary. Indeed, I conclude with a set of open-ended questions whose answers I do not provide because I do not have them. In the introduction of his magnus opus, Capital, Karl Marx famously cautioned that “there is no royal road to science, and only those who do not dread the fatiguing climb of its steep paths have a chance of gaining its luminous summits.” There are a few dense passages in the present work that I have tried, with a limited degree of success, to make intelligible to an audience not versed in political economy. I recommend Hadas Their’s A People’s Guide to Capitalism to those readers who seek an eminently readable introduction to the political economy of capitalism.20 In recent years there have been dozens, perhaps hundreds, of studies on the crisis that began with the 2008 global financial meltdown that build on over a century of literature from a Marxist perspective on capitalist crisis. Among those the reader may find useful is Michael Roberts’ The Long Depression.21 I have strived here to find a balance in which this short work is accessible to a general readership concerned with the urgent political affairs of our day yet also satisfying to scholars of global political economy. Both sets of readers will have to decide if I have achieved this goal. If the history of capitalism is one of never-ending transformation, crises often mark before-and-after turning points. The period from 2008, when the global financial system collapsed, into the third decade of the twenty-first century has been one long protracted crisis that, far from being resolved, became aggravated by the coronavirus pandemic. This crisis is as much economic, or structural, as it is political, or one of state legitimacy and capitalist hegemony.22 It is also existential because of the danger of ecological collapse as well as the renewed threat of nuclear war, to which we must add the risk of future pandemics that may involve much deadlier microbes than coronaviruses. It is an organic crisis insofar as it is not static: it comes from deep within the contradictions of capitalist development and its multiple dimensions presuppose one another. Can global capitalism endure? Indeed, will humanity survive? These are, to be sure, two distinct questions. It is entirely possible that the system itself endures even as a majority of humanity faces desperate struggles for survival that lead many to perish in the coming years and decades. Crises are endemic to capitalism. The entire 500-plus year history of world capitalism is marked by successive crises that have at their height shaken the system to its core. Each major crisis has involved predictions that the system would collapse in on itself in the face of intractable contradictions. Yet capitalism has repeatedly proved to be more resilient and adaptable than its doomsday forecasters. As we shall explore in this short work, the system has been undergoing a new round of restructuring and transformation since the financial collapse of 2008, based on a much more advanced digitalization of the entire global economy and society. The coronavirus contagion has turbo-charged these transformations and also allowed the ruling groups to ramp up their surveillance and control of restive populations.23 The agents of global capitalism are now attempting to purchase a new lease on life for the system through this digital restructuring and through reforms that some among the global elite are advocating in the face of mass pressures from below. If some regulatory or redistributive reform actually comes to pass, restructuring may—depending on the play of social and class forces—unleash a new round of productive expansion that attenuates the crisis. In the long run, however, it is difficult to see how global capitalism can continue to reproduce itself without a much more profound overhaul than is currently on the horizon, if not the outright overthrow of the system. In the history of capitalism there have been periodic crises of two types, cyclical and structural. Cyclical crises, sometimes called the business cycle, occur about once a decade and show up as recessions. There were recessions in the early 1980s, the early 1990s, and at the turn of the twenty-first century. World capitalism has experienced over the past two centuries several episodes of structural crisis, or what I call restructuring crises, so-called because the resolution of such crises requires a major restructuring of the system. Here “resolution” means displacement in time and space through restructuring that paves the way for a new burst of sustained accumulation and outward expansion after a period of stagnation and malaise. Eventually the underlying contradictions of the system build up and erupt into new crises, often triggered by a precipitating event, such as the bursting of a speculative bubble or a political watershed moment. The first Great Depression from the 1870s into the 1890s led to the great wave of late nineteenth century imperialism, the rise of powerful national corporations, and ultimately to the First World War and the Bolshevik Revolution. The Great Depression in the 1930s sparked intense worldwide class struggles and political upheavals, bringing in their wake fascism, the Second World War, and eventually the consolidation of a new model of redistributive or regulated capitalism. Known as the New Deal in the United States and elsewhere as social democracy, what we can call more technically Fordist-Keynesian capitalism established the basis for the post-WWII boom, the so-called golden age of capitalism. Fordism refers to the system of standardized mass production and mass consumption introduced originally by Henry Ford. Keynesianism refers to the economic doctrine of John Maynard Keynes, who had broken with the assumptions of classical economic theory that the natural state of the economy was an equilibrium so long as market forces were allowed to operate unimpeded. Instead, he argued, the state had to intervene to regulate the market and generate aggregate demand through credit and employment creation, progressive taxation, and government spending on public works and social programs. The two combined—Fordism and Keynesianism—involved regulation and redistribution in what came to be considered a “class compromise,” mediated by the state, between the working classes and capital.24 Structural crisis hit again in the 1970s, characterized this time by “stagflation,” or the combination of stagnation and inflation. The Fordist-Keynesian “class compromise” was imposed on capital through decades of intense worldwide class and social struggles and the devastation of two world wars. But eventually, redistribution and regulation cut into capitalist power. As stagnation set in, the working and popular classes in each nation-state resisted the effort by capitalists and governments to place the burden of the crisis on their shoulders.25 As class struggle intensified, capitalists and bureaucratic elites from around the world strove to beat back the power of organized labor, radical social movements, and Third World liberation struggles. Capitalists turned to leveraging globalization as a strategy to undercut the power that working and popular classes could exercise within the state; to break free of state constraints to its freedom to accumulate. At its core, globalization is class warfare from above: capital’s drive to revert the global correlation of class and social forces to its advantage. As capital went global, a transnational capitalist class (TCC) emerged in the late twentieth century, forged out of the transnational integration of the leading sectors among national capitalist classes, and consisting of the owners and managers of the giant transnational corporations and financial conglomerates that now drive the global economy.26 Globalization allowed this TCC and its political and bureaucratic agents in states and international agencies to dismantle diverse forms of redistributive or social democratic capitalism and to restore the class power of capital by reorganizing the worldwide circuits of accumulation. This restructuring process has involved above all the rise of a globally integrated production, financial and service system into which every country has been integrated. Global trade as a share of global output jumped from 30 percent in 1970 to 60 percent in the early 2010s.27 But this trade was less in finished goods than in the movement of intermediate goods through numerous nodes in global supply and production chains—a functional integration in which intermediate goods accounted for nearly 60 percent of all trade by the 2010s.28 Hence, unlike the situation in earlier structural crises, in this age of global capitalism the world economy is now inextricably integrated and functions as a single unit in real time. The global fragmentation and decentralization of production and finance around the world brought about by globalization has been marked by the inverse centralization of command and control in a handful of ever more powerful transnational corporations and financial conglomerates at the command of the TCC. As we shall see momentarily, the current crisis is set apart from all earlier ones insofar as it is internal to global capitalism as a whole. National withdrawal from the global economy is entirely out of the question, as are “national” solutions to the global crisis. Liberation from the nation-state may have enhanced the structural power of capital over working and popular classes struggling within the bounds of the nation-state. But at the same time, globalization has ended up exacerbating the underlying contradictions of capitalism. Moreover, it has made it more difficult for states to impose any modicum of regulation on the global market that could help ameliorate the crisis and restabilize the system.