Focus on policy agenda influence ignores the concrete material praxis needed for broad social transformation
Wigger 18 [Angela, Assoc Prof in Global Political Economy at Radboud Univ, “From dissent to resistance: Locating patterns of horizontalist self-management crisis responses in Spain,” Comparative European Politics 16.1, p.34-5, JCR]
A historical materialist approach gives ontological primacy to historically specific socio-economic realities constituted by the social relations of production and the collective class agency emanating from it. It allows for systematically analysing clusters of class action in a historical context of broader ideational and material structures of power and counterpower. As an emancipatory project, changing the social relations of production is considered the groundwork for a wider social transformation. Analyses in the historical materialist tradition however often suffer from an elitist bias by focusing overwhelmingly on the role and internal fractionation of capital (Wigger and Horn, 2014). Social struggles consequently tend to be reduced to top-down institutional arrangements securing domination within the state apparatus, while dissent, disruption, protest and resistance outside the remit of the state institutional realm, such as demonstrations, strikes, square occupations, as well as more concrete material economic practices, remain analytically and theoretically marginalized (Huke et al, 2015). Emerging forms of resistance are consequently often perceived as limited or as reactive only (Featherstone, 2015). Social movement literatures in contrast clearly give primacy to bottom-up political struggles but often suffer from a similar state-centric bias by focusing predominantly on political demands by social movements vis-a-vis the established state institutional arena, and henceforth, their successes in influencing the policy agenda (McAdam et al, 2001; Tarrow, 2012; Della Porta, 2013). Tarrow (2011: 9), for example, conceptualizes social movements as ‘collective challenges, based on common purposes and social solidarities, in sustained interaction with elites, opponents, and authorities’. Such a state-centric institutional reductionism is problematic insofar as it tends to ignore forms of concrete material radical praxis that takes place outside the realm of state institutional pressure politics of political parties, trade unions, interest groups, advocacy networks or NGOs and that challenges the very status quo of how the (re-)production of everyday life through work is organized. As a result, the traditional social movement literature has paid little attention to forms of resistance in the form of alternative social relations of (re-)production and the redistribution of material resources. Collective action is moreover frequently portrayed as classless. Certainly, not all forms of collective action are necessarily rooted in class or class awareness; yet, such agency may nonetheless have ‘conjuncturally determined’ class relevance (Jessop, 2002: 32).