3. Pragmatism DA – the perm keeps its foot in the door of neoliberalism as a pragmatic move in the face of neoliberal subject formation – that’s a fatalistic move that captures the alt
Reed 18
(Patricia Reed obtained her BFA from Concordia University, Montreal, and an MA in communications from the European Graduate School, Switzerland. She has been a grant recipient from the Canada Council of the Arts, Akademie Schloss Solitude, Stuttgart (Germany); CCA Kitakyushu (Japan); Foundation and Centre for Contemporary Art Prague, (Czech Rep.); The Banff Centre for the Arts (Canada); and the CCA Ujazdowski, Warsaw (Poland). She was Canada Council Artist in Residence at the Cité des Arts in Paris, 2016. “Optimist Realism: Finance and the Politicization of Anticipation” MoneyLab Reader 2: Overcoming the Hype, 18 January 2018, )
Petrified Futurity Capitalist Realism indexes not only our economic condition, but more pervasively, the 'atmosphere' of political resignation which denies the possibility for any other socio-economic structural scenario. This 'atmosphere' permeates both conscious and unconscious life, including the arena of cultural production (music, art, film, etc.) where instead of seeing boundless innovation (a capitalist premise), we seem caught in retroparalysis: loops of re-makes and pop-cultural revivalism,5 where substantial technological development devolves into trivial consumer gadgetry.' Within such an atmosphere, mental distress and illness has also proliferated as a debilitating symp- tom of the behavioral imperatives this naturalization entails. This is in the way one is compelled to 'govern from within' to adapt to the world successfully in full, entrepre- neurial self-reliance. Such naturalization is internalized as the only system compat- ible with 'innate' humanness, where this picture of 'innateness' is both self-referential and self-reinforcing, coercing the human into a narrow mold wherein the incentive of accumulation through competition is isomorphic with our 'intrinsic' selfishness and self-interest (those very social biases buttressing neoclassical economics, upon which neoliberalism is built). In this framing, capitalism is upheld as the only system com- mensurate with the 'nature' of the human; to suggest otherwise is to fall prey to folly, almost as nonsensical as fighting the fact of gravity on earth. The diagnosis Fisher puts forth, quite pointedly, is that Capitalist Realism petrifies politics because it stifles our imaginative and perspectival horizons. The axiom then gets extrapolated: if futurity is always a political project and politics is dead-locked, our future, as such, has become cancelled - a point to which we will return.