Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Green capitalism is the primary driver of modern accumulation – the aff appropriates ecological crisis to serve the ideological framework of capital

Nikula 17 [Ilari, PhD Researcher in Social and Economic Geography at the University of Lapland; "Neoliberal Environmentalism," 08/06/17, http://web.isanet.org/Web/Conferences/HKU2017-s/Archive/ceb6c473-5cb9-4308-9e23-efe6157f7785.pdf]

Mueller and Passadakis (2009; 2010) have argued that the ecological crisis has been placed at the heart of the growth strategy of the present neoliberal regime. They point that green capitalism is now the main driver of a new round of capitalist accumulation. This is seen, for example, in initiatives like The Green New Deal (GND) that was announced by the United Nations Environmental Programme (UNEP) in 2008. It is a proposed set of policy proposals that aim to address global warming and financial crisis. They include schemes for reducing incentives to invest in ‘dirty’ over ‘clean’ industries, creating systematic measurements for ecosystem valuations, like consistent global carbon, emissions and water charges (UNEP 2011, 9, 14, 29). These proposals also strive for trade liberalization, safeguarding market access of individuals, credit availability and microcredit programmes (ibid., 9-10, 31, 34). Green parties that are pushing the GND policies are hailed as a “market-friendly engine of innovation” and the GND is described as a “stimulus package for the ecological technologies of the future” (Mueller and Passadakis 2009, 55). The director of UNEP summed it up when announcing UNEP’s two-year GND project in 2008: “The new, green economy would provide a new engine of growth, putting the world on the road to prosperity again” (quoted in Mueller and Passadakis 2010, 560). Indeed, UNEP (2011, 38) further defines that the so-called “trade-off” between economic progress and environmental sustainability is a myth. GND proposals have been criticized, especially in the developing countries, in that they undermine national sovereignty, set a green "normative straightjacket" for developing countries, and that they signal a "privatization and commodification of nature” (Vedeld 2011, 28). Critics also refer that these global prescriptions consider too little the local consequences of such solutions, saying that local solutions might have much more potential in terms of their sustainability (ibid., 16). Mueller and Passadakis (2010, 555) suggest that the ecological threat has given global institutions like World Bank, IMF, WTO and G8 a way to overcome the legitimation problem they have been having. If there ever was a real antagonism between environmental reason and neoliberal capitalism, it has now been internalized by both.2 In addition to the policies of global institutions, this has also happened in our everyday lives, inasmuch as “sustainability [has become] a political attitude of the multitude” (Parr 2009, 4). Slavoj Žižek (2009) notes that consuming has now become ecologically ethical. Consuming has become an act for the environment as ‘green’ and ‘socially responsible’ companies claim to sell an ethical framework as well as a product, thus freeing buyers from the distasteful role of being merely consumers. In products labeled e.g. “environmentally friendly” one doesn’t buy just a product, one buys, in the very consumerist act, a “redemption from being only a consumerist.” One act of egotist consumerism, but within it one pairs for being redeemed for it as the “act of egotist consumption already includes the price for its ethical opposite.” Save the planet by shopping.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.