Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Even best case UBI gets coopted or circumvented through other economic means

Lyon 21 [Rob, International Coordinator for Socialist Action/Ligue pour lÁction Socialiste, political organizer for the New Democratic Youth, “Canada: socialism or UBI?” 03/01/21, https://www.marxist.com/canada-socialism-ubi.htm]

An added weakness of UBI is that even when it is proposed with the best of reformist intentions, the fact that it is also being put forward by the right wing means that it is open to co-option. A Liberal government fighting to survive may rhetorically adopt UBI to steal NDP votes, only to turn around and use it as a fig-leaf for cuts in social programs. An NDP government capitulating to capitalist pressure could do something similar, jettisoning the expansion of the welfare state and corporate taxes, leaving behind only a cash payment funded via deficits and inflation. The left-UBIers also cannot escape the problem of any proposal to tax the rich while they continue owning the means of production. Any plan that genuinely taxes the rich and redistributes wealth will not be accepted by the capitalists. If you tax the rich they will not invest. They will take their capital overseas, close factories and make millions unemployed. This is why the key question is not taxation and redistribution, but ownership. You cannot plan what you do not control and you cannot control what you do not own.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.