Social Security is a governmental technology of control designed to stabilize capitalism from its failures – coopting revolutionary class struggle and restoring confidence in capitalist organization
Brents 84 [Barbara, Prof of Sociology at UNLV, “Capitalism, Corporate Liberalism and Social Policy: The Origins of the Social Security Act of 1935,” Mid-American Review of Sociology, p.25-7]
Social insurance as we know it had its earliest intellectual roots in the late 19th century transformation of liberal thought from an individualist laissez faire ideology to the social responsibility, interventionist ideology of the 20th century. It was the view of this new corporate liberalism that provided justifications and methods for social insurance in America, along a course that was entirely consistent with the continuance of a capitalist system. Twentieth century corporate "liberalism, as James Weinstein (1968) defines it, involves an ideology which holds that social engineering, social efficiency and social responsibility are the means to stabilize, rationalize and expand the existing capitalist political economy, and avoid dangerous alternate forms of social organization, especially socialism. In the attempt to succeed in this endeavor, the economist arose as the technical expert who would develop government policy that could create and maintain a stable social order. As corporate liberalism developed, it succeeded in co-opting a potentially radical and often violent working class by incorporating labor representatives as junior partners in a business/government association designed to work out "rational" and "efficient" solutions to conflicts and maintain industrial peace'. Terms such as efficiency and stabilization replaced justice as the main expressed goal. However, corporate liberalism, as it shall be discussed throughout this paper, cannot be viewed as a static, autonomous concept. It was a dynamic set of ideas that originated in the minds of humans and was both shaped by and shaped interaction in a social environment. This ideology laid the intellectual groundwork, set the ideological boundaries, and devised the methods used in the formulation of the Social Security Act as "the" solution to the problems of old age and unemployment. Corporate liberal ideas originated in Germany in the late 187Os and were first brought to the United States by a group of prominent American economists trained in the German Historical School of Economics centered at the University of Heidelberg. Contrary to classical economics and its abstract reasoning and individualistic emphasis on natural rights and natural law, this group believed economic phenomena could best be understood by using statistical investigations and inductive methods to shape economic institutions to meet social goals through active state intervention. The members of this school formed the Union for Social Politics (Verein fiir Sozialpolitik) in Germany to gather economic information to meet "the acknowledged need ... of social reform in -opposition to social revolution on the one hand, and to rigid laissez faire on the other" (Dorfman, 1955 :21). These attempts to "meet the challenge of socialism resulted in an advanced program of social insurance, culminating in Bismark's program of sickness, accident, invalidity and old age insurance" (Dorfman, 1955 :21). The American economists from this school returned to the United States with these ideas during the late 1880s and 90s, years fraught with long and severe depressions and widespread labor unrest. Many, including some businessmen, were losing confidence in the ability of an unregulated economy to maintain social order, and these economists did much to change the scope of American economics. The work of Richard Ely in particular helped define and institutionalize emerging corporate 'liberal 'thought and subsequent notions of social insurance. Ely, impressed with the efficiency of the German government, believed the United States government could likewise efficiently shape economic life for the good of the public. He outlined programs of social reform that resembled those of the New Deal over 40 years later public housing, public work for the unemployed, child and female labor restrictions, and government insurance for protection against death, old age, sickness and accidents (Fine, 1956; Ely, 1894). His reforms had the expressed goals of avoiding socialist- violence and revolution, and maintaining the existing class structure by eliminating the waste and inefficiency of the present system (Fine, 1956; Ely, 1894). Ely published 25 books and 280 pamphlets and articles before his death in 1937. His students included a long list of New Dealers, reformists, economists, sociologists and others who became important in forming American social policy during the first half of the twentieth century