Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The historical record proves that social security has been about stabilization of capitalist industrial interests from the start – it has been the tool for exclusion of radical alternatives from policy debates

Brents 84 [Barbara, Prof of Sociology at UNLV, “Capitalism, Corporate Liberalism and Social Policy: The Origins of the Social Security Act of 1935,” Mid-American Review of Sociology, p.35-7]

The political history of the Social Security bill demonstrates clearly the carrying out of the corporate liberal link between business, academicians and government. Swope and Young actively advised Roosevelt up until he appointed the Committee on Economic Security to research and write the bill, and the Committee was careful to carry out Roosevelt's wishes (Witte, 1962). Key positions on this committee were held by Wisconsin group people and AALL members, and a majority of the participants were connected in some way to corporate liberal organizations. The advisory council to the committee consisted of labor representatives, "public" members and business leaders. The businessmen were clearly those who were connected to corporate liberal ideas. There was much debate within this committee, and in Congress on the specific details of the bill, but overall the Social Security Act was framed in corporate liberal terms. In fact, the bill changed little once it was in Congress. Indeed, there were only two radical alternatives put before Congress at that time: the Townsend Bill (advocating $200 per month for everyone over 60) and the Lundeen Bill (advocating benefits equal to average local wages to all workers and farmers over 18 who were unemployed through no fault of their own). But neither of these bills, nor working class movements, nor general non-corporate liberal business opposition could legitimately enter the policy making process once the basic outlines were formulated. The corporate liberal ideology had clear hegemony and dominated Congressional debates. A survey of Congressional hearings shows that stabilization of industry was the dominant theme and debates among those involved in government, the Committee on Economic Security, and liberal industry centered around the best method of stabilization. In justifying the act to Congress, administration spokespersons, including advisory council member Marion Folsom of Kodak and. other businessmen supporting the act, emphasized that unemployment insurance would stabilize the labor force as well as purchasing power, hence giving employers more predictable markets. Even old age insurance was viewed in terms of stabilization and efficiency. According to a report published by the Social Security Board (1937:199), old age insurance was created to enhance the elderly's sense of security and confidence, get old people out of the labor market and stabilize their consumption expenditures. Hence, old age insurance was viewed as helping to solve part of the unemployment problem, a problem viewed more in terms of the inefficiency of industry rather than the effects on the worker. According to Murray Latimer, who helped write the old age provisions of the Act: There are a number of industrial companies who's level of productive efficiency has been and is being reduced by the fact that they have a number of old men whom they would like to retire but cannot on account of public pressure, and at the same time they have not sufficient funds available to start a pension system (Latimer, Senate Finance Committee Hearings, 1935:749). After explaining how benefits would induce elders to leave the labor force, increase wages, absorb the young employed and also take the burden of support off their children, Latimer added, "nor should the advantages of the maintenance of a large and continuing stream of purchasing power directed almost entirely to consumer goods be overlooked" (Ways and Means Committee Hearings, 1935:223-4). The advantages for the stabilization of industry via production and consumption was the central theme of the debates on old age insurance. The development of corporate liberalism from the German Historical School through the research and policy planning organizations composed of capitalists and academics gradually altered views toward social insurance by encouraging businesses to believe it could help expand their industries as well as ensure social peace. Industrial and social rationalization and stabilization; and, the social benefits of a more efficient corporate system were the key values. The policy planning 'groups involved the same businessmen and academics who would later help formulate the Social Security Act. These groups and certain liberal businessmen began to participate in government studies on unemployment insurance and began to push for state legislation and private pension plans that would serve as exemplars for the Social Security Act. These exemplars specifically centered on rationalizing and stabilizing industry. Social justice for the worker was a subsidiary concern. The Social Security Act was a culmination of corporate liberal ideas on unemployment-the need to have predictable and efficient labor and consumer markets through payments to those previously tied to the labor market, and the need to smooth out business cycles. Old age insurance was likewise viewed as a means to remove inefficient older workers from the labor force and put more money in consumers' pockets. In addition, both unemployment and old age insurance were contingent on labor force participation and in fact excluded large numbers of the labor force that were not tied to mainstream industry (such as agricultural workers, domestic servants and seamen), reinforcing dependency on the labor market for subsistence. Hence the Act was formulated with the interests of industry foremost.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.