Environmentalism is the newest neoliberal mechanism used entrench neoliberal governance
Nikula, PhD Researcher in Social and Economic Geography, 17
Ilari Nikula, PhD Researcher in Social and Economic Geography at the University of Lapland. Neoliberal Environmentalism, , 08/06/17, DOA: 06/19/23. AR
In the public discourse it is generally viewed that environmentalism acts as a counterforce to neoliberalism, or as a limiting force to capitalism. Adopting the global environmental discourse is often seen as opposing the injustices created by the current capitalist system and the only alternative to accepting the logic of current neoliberal system. The global environmental cause, and primarily the climate change, is to be understood as a weapon to use in an ideological struggle. Naomi Klein’s book ‘This Changes Everything: Climate versus Capitalism’ (Klein 2014) is a good illustration of this position. Klein makes explicit this instrumental role that climate change plays for her: “I realized the science of global warming … could be a catalyst for forms of social and economic justice in which I already believed” [p.59]. In this manner, as Hulme (2015) has noted, climate change thus becomes a synedoche for the evils of global capitalism. This paper examines this relation of environmentalism to neoliberalism. But, on the contrary, the aim of this paper is to offer a rebuttal, contrary arguments to the above-mentioned understanding. The paper presents a perspective that sees the concern for global environmental degradation as a source on which new neoliberal governance structures have been created and which strengthens the underpinnings of the current neoliberal frameworks of power. Since the birth of modern environmental discourse some scholars have pointed out the implicit consequences of global environmental concerns that are complicit with and supportive of the growth neoliberal systems of governance (Golub and Townsend 1977). Today, there is an established academic discussion on neoliberal environment. It is discussed from different perspectives and in different contexts by, for example, Heynen et al. (2007), McCarthy & Prudham (2004), Robertson (2004), Mueller and Passadakis (2009; 2010), Hajer (1995), Crawford (2009), Swyngedouw (2010), Escobar (1996), Luke (1997), Shantz (2003), and Bachram (2004), Spehr 1999, and Reid (2012a). This literature considers the ways in which environmental governance, and environmentalism as a set of political movements, coincide, articulate, and even constitute the emergence of global neoliberal frameworks. A central theme in the literature is that the primary response of the global environmental regime to the environmental crisis during the last few decades has been marked by a massive expansion in ‘environmental finance’. From ‘carbon markets’ to ‘pollution permits’, ‘climate derivatives’ and ‘catastrophe bonds’, we are seeing a proliferation of nature-related financial products. The past few decades have witnessed a rapid increase in the involvement of private corporations in resource ownership, and the provision of ‘ecosystem services’. Simultaneously, markets and market proxies have been deployed as mechanisms of environmental governance at multiple scales. The concept of nature as capital has gained visibility in policies and practices in both the public and private sectors. The environmentalism this regime is pushing forward is certainly not limiting neoliberalism. Here the conception of ‘global environment’ and its crisis, has by itself been the argument why all aspects if nature need to be marketisized. Today, the real or presumed environmental crisis can be seen as an engine of neoliberalization of our world. Invoking environmental crisis has strategically functioned in the global expansion of neoliberalism by naturalising its frameworks of governance. In this sense, the arguments presented in this paper are putting the ecological crisis upside-down: environmentalism that appears a threat to the system now becomes a vehicle for its very innovation.