Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Leftist criticism of the GND is misplaced – vesting workers with power pressures private employers away from violent exploitative practices

Guastella, director of operations for Teamsters Local 623, 2022 (Dustin, Teamsters is a North American labor union, 2022, “Jobs for All: A Job Guarantee Puts Workers in the Driver’s Seat,” Chapter 7 in The Green New Deal and the Future of Work, p. 155-156, https://www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.7312/calh20556-007/html, GDI-MAM).

The demand for “jobs for all” was, in some form or another, a cornerstone of the Left’s political agenda in the 1930s and 1940s. Unfortunately, in the postwar decades and beyond, the demand to end unemployment altogether was repeatedly thwarted or shelved. And with the decline of the Left’s political fortunes, the imaginative vision of an economy free from joblessness faded from memory for nearly a half century. Today, thanks especially to Bernie Sanders, the call for a right to a job is once again gaining momentum. What’s more, as advocates push for a Green New Deal, a federal job guarantee appears an effective means of tackling both the economic and environmental challenges we face in the near future.1

Naturally, the contemporary demand for a job guarantee has been dismissed by the business press as “absurd” and unworkable.2 Meanwhile, liberal outfits have urged caution and restraint.3 This sort of hostility is to be expected; after all, a federal job guarantee would cost in excess of $500 billion, and the political ideas that inform such a program have not been up for serious debate since the 1970s.4 Additionally, a federal job guarantee would undermine the logic of a ruthless labor market, challenge management’s absolute power over employees, and vastly improve workers’ leverage on the job. Elites are justifiably worried, defensive, and lashing out.

What is less expected, however, has been the skepticism of the job guarantee idea expressed by some on the political Left, even from advocates of the Green New Deal. Some claim the program would not challenge the form of the wage relation itself, or that it would be logistically impossible to administer— that its realization would result in nightmarish work camps or that it would end up looking like Clintonian workfare on steroids. Much of this skepticism comes from those who advocate for a basic income as a solution to the challenges of the contemporary labor market. Ironically, what the business press gets exactly right about a job guarantee is what most skeptics get wrong. Tightening the labor market would ratchet up pressure on private employers to raise wages and massively increase the size of the federally employed workforce. Employment assurance programs have historically evoked elite pearl- clutching precisely because they are among the few political demands that put workers in a position of real power. Criticism of a job guarantee, then, reflects a misunderstanding of the political logic of such a proposal: the power that a job guarantee affords workers; the sheer scale of the industrial restructuring needed to reduce inequality, raise wages, and mitigate climate change; and, finally, the central and enduring role of wage labor in socialist strategy.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.