Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Job Guarantee is a nonreformist reform that empowers the working class and enables broader opposition to capital

Anastasi 21 [Anthony William Donald, PhD Candidate in Politics at East China Normal University, “Marxism and MMT,” World Review of Political Economy 12.4]

A grasp of MMT could make the implementation of reforms that could push society past capitalism more feasible. For those who wish to do away with capitalism, not just reform it, there are certain reforms that can help lead us to the economic system that will succeed capitalism. These reforms would not stagnate us into perpetual capitalism; they could change the way we think about work, the way we produce, and the way we live. It could help democratize the economy in multiple ways. This section of the article will explore a Job Guarantee and publicly funded elections. The cost of the programs inhibits a true political discussion in the United States, yet an understanding of MMT could allow these ideas to become a reality. By no means are these two policies the only non-reformist reforms that could help society evolve from capitalism, yet they are looked at since the first could enhance the economic power of the working class, and the second could increase the political power of the working class and other disadvantaged communities. 3.1 Job Guarantee The logical conclusion of MMT is a Job Guarantee (JG). In Kelton’s The Deficit Myth, the JG acts as its centerpiece policy prescription (2020). A JG would establish and institutionalize an extensive public option for employment. A JG would codify the right to a job in law and make the government the employer of last resort (ELR) for any resident willing and able to work, thereby eliminating both involuntary unemployment and poverty (Paul et al. 2018). A JG would ideally work by being centrally funded (or at whatever governmental level issues the currency) and be locally administered. A JG would set up a two-tier labor market, a private and public one, where the government would set the lowest acceptable wage and working conditions for labor. Most of the time, the JG wage would be fixed as a means of price stability, yet it would need to raise gradually as time goes on. The government would be able to exercise full control over the public sector and by competition, would influence the private-sector labor market. Since labor in the private sector could always quit and get a guaranteed job in the public sector, it would raise workers bargaining power when negotiating with their employers, especially those whose wages are closest to the floor set by the JG. A JG could do away with minimum wage laws for full-time employment, as there would be no need. The government would set the floor for both wages and working conditions, so in order for private employers to attract workers, they would have to compete with the public sector. It could help Marxists achieve goals such as raising the material conditions and working conditions of many lower-wage workers and ending involuntary unemployment (Tcherneva 2018). Argentina’s experiment shows that a JG can have positive effects (Wray 2006). As well as empowering labor, it could work to fight racial inequality within states that would adopt it. In the United States, black unemployment is consistently double that of whites, and in some months, college-educated black Americans have a higher unemployment rate when compared to white Americans without a college degree (Paul et al. 2018). The way in which MMT has us think about unemployment shares similarities to Marxist theory. Through the lens of MMT, unemployment is a policy choice, as the government lowers aggregate demand by the taxes it imposes on the masses (Mitchell 2010). The only way to pay these taxes is by obtaining the currency that only the government can produce. By not having a sufficient fiscal policy that brings the economy to full employment, the government is choosing to have involuntary unemployment. Involuntary unemployment creates the reserve army of labor which Marx wrote about in the first volume of Capital. This does serve the capitalist class, as full employment would put pressure on wages, thus eating into the capitalists’ profits. A JG would end the reserve army of labor and push power away from employers to employees. A JG would also act as a price stabilizer, and keep inflation manageable. Currently, capitalist economies rely on the Non-Accelerating Inflation Rate of Unemployment (NAIRU) to control prices. According to this theory, there is a “natural rate of unemployment,” and getting unemployment below this rate should spur inflation. Ever since the adoption of this approach, central banks and policy-makers have been keeping unemployment above its estimated natural rate of unemployment, which is believed to be about 4.5% in the United States as of 2020 (U.S. Congressional Budget Office 2021). This flawed approach perpetually locks millions out of employment, and the sheer threat of inflation could lead to more losing their job. A JG would achieve true full employment, meaning employing anyone who wants and is able to work, and price stability by shifting to the Non-Accelerating Inflation Buffer Employment Rate (NAIBER) approach (Mitchell 1998). The NAIBER would allow the government to control inflation by adjusting the ratio between private and public sector workers. Instead of using the unemployed as a buffer stock against inflation as the NAIRU approach would suggest, a buffer stock of those employed by the JG would be used. Since the government would set the wage floor for those in the JG program, in times of bad economic conditions, it would prevent any grave deflation. Though in times of good economic conditions, the private labor market would become tighter, and the pool of those in the JG would shrink, decreasing the Buffer Employment Ratio (BER), which is the ratio of those in the JG compared to total employment. This means that there would be upwards pressure on wages in the private market, but not in the JG as that wage is fixed. If this pressure on wages spurs inflation, the government could impose economic discipline, such as fiscal tightening or raising the interest rate. Though some proponents of MMT would only suggest fiscal tightening as they would like to keep the Fed funds rate at zero (Forstater and Mosler 2005). This discipline would lead to layoffs in private-sector employment, moving workers into the JG program and increasing the BER. This would assuage inflationary pressures as the JG wage would be fixed. Through fiscal and monetary policy, the government can adjust the BER and keep inflation manageable and predictable while maintaining proper full employment at all times. A JG could help democratize the economy. It would give the government, a public institution, massive influence over the economy. The law could be written in a manner that these public sector jobs could extract less surplus value from workers when compared to private-sector jobs, though avoiding surplus value extraction altogether might be impossible (Mahoney 2021). This could rewrite society’s expectations of work, leading to perpetual demands of better working conditions in both the public and private sectors. A JG could bring the benefit of ending the economic costs of involuntary unemployment, such as a lower GDP, and also the substantial human costs. The human costs of unemployment are far-reaching and are usually understated when discussing this topic. The most obvious is that being unemployed makes finding future employment harder (Ho et al. 2012) and decreases lifetime earnings (Gregg and Tominey 2005). It affects your emotional and mental health for the worse (Farré, Fasani, and Mueller 2018). It damages relationships and your family life (McClelland 2000). It makes you more likely to use drugs (Peck and Plant 1986) and commit acts of violence (Cramer 2011). It also leads to an increased likelihood of injury, suicide, and death in general (Voss et al. 2004). The human costs of involuntary unemployment are detrimental to both society and the individual. These costs of unemployment coupled with the benefits a JG would bring such as ending the reserve army of labor, empowering workers and marginalized communities when bargaining for wages, raising working conditions and wages, stabilizing prices, and democratization of the economy should make implementing a JG a priority for Marxists.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.