Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Megatrends are wrong – cap is sustainable — dematerialization is working

Wright 20, program director for MIT’s Office of Corporate Relations. (Randall S., April 21st, “Forget Megatrends . . . Find and Follow Movements”, Research-Technology Management, 63:3, pg. 55-58, https://doi.org/10.1080/08956308.2020.1733897, accessed 2-23-2022)

More and more firms are looking to megatrends to try to ascertain an unfolding future and plan strategy for the long term. The idea seems to be to take a megatrend, find a subtrend within it, and then distill the subtrend into new product or business opportunities. Yet in my discussions with executives, most report limited success trying to turn analyses of megatrends into concrete and actionable activities. Why is that? Is there a better way to act for the future than contemplating megatrends?

For starters, megatrends are vague. And that’s the main reason they sound so convincing and inevitable. They’re seductive, just like horoscopes: “There will be about 1 billion more of us by 2030, and we will live longer” (Winston 2019). Can’t argue with that. “With relentless planet Mars at the helm, an investment, real estate, or financial matter could pay dividends, but it will come with many demands” (ELLE 2020). I can see that happening. But so what? That there might be “about 1 billion more of us by 2030,” or that “an investment . . . could pay dividends . . . with many demands,” leaves us dangling. Like horoscopes, the first problem with megatrends is that despite their sounding so satisfying and compelling, they’re just too nebulous to take meaningful actions.

In Megatrends, the book that started it all, author John Naisbitt begins by stating that none of the 10 transformations his book is about “is more subtle, yet more explosive . . . than the shift from an industrial to an information society” (Naisbitt 1982, p. 11). He was right. And? He failed to predict not only the iPhone but the Macintosh computer (“the Mac”), the World Wide Web, Internet of Things, radio frequency identification (RFID), global positioning systems (GPS), and social media—the meaningful inventions to which we really need to pay heed and that have caused, and will continue to cause, major changes in how we live.

But it gets worse—a lot worse. That’s because megatrends are frequently wrong—way wrong. In 1956, legendary geologist M. King Hubbert predicted that US petroleum production would peak in 1970 with oil running out in 2015 (Novak 2014). In his best-selling 1968 book, The Population Bomb, Stanford biologist Dr. Paul Ehrlich predicted, “The battle to feed all of humanity is over. In the 1970s hundreds of millions of people will starve to death in spite of any crash programs embarked upon now. At this late date nothing can prevent a substantial increase in the world death rate” (Ehrlich 1968, p. 11). Harrison Brown, a scientist at the National Academy of Sciences, published a chart in Scientific American that looked at metal reserves and estimated that humanity would totally run out of copper shortly after 2000. Lead, zinc, tin, gold, and silver would be gone before 1990 (Brown 1970). Needless to say, none of it happened.

In his book More from Less, Andrew McAfee, principal research scientist at MIT Sloan School of Management, suggests technology and capitalism are why predictions of the future are frequently so terribly wrong. Essentially, humans invent things to empower themselves and subvert material shortages, while capitalism—Schumpeter’s “creative destruction” (Alm and Cox 2020) fueled by capitalism’s price mechanism that allocates resources to their most highly valued use—takes them mainstream. Together they’re why megatrends get derailed. It’s why and how we invent ways to grow more food, find more oil, and better use materials.

Here is one example of current megatrends from “The World in 2030: Nine Megatrends to Watch” that is currently being displaced by meaningful inventions:

Transparency: Our world will become even more open—and less private. It’s hard to imagine that the trend to track everything will be going anywhere but one direction: a radically open world. The amount of information collected on every person . . . will grow exponentially . . . The tools to analyze information will be well-developed . . . But, all these tools will shatter privacy in the process (Winston 2019).

Sounds bleak—except that a movement to ensure data privacy is already well underway, both in software and hardware. In 2015, MIT professor Nikolai Zeldovich developed Vuvuzela, a private chat application that hides metadata, including who you chat with and when you are chatting. Vuvuzela supports millions of users and is secure even if the network and most of the servers are compromised by powerful nation-state hackers with capabilities like the US National Security Agency.

MIT professors Vivienne Sze and Max Shulaker are creating new chip architectures that will enable artificial intelligence (AI) to run locally on mobile devices. Instead of transmitting personal data to the cloud, processing occurs locally so only answers or results are transmitted, keeping personal data secure on devices: “We’re developing systems that enable efficient processing of visual data, so we can disconnect the processing from the cloud and bring it to the edge or the palm of your hand,” says Sze. “We want to send only relevant information to the cloud or maybe no information at all” (Brown 2018).

For people who want to keep their personal data private, a movement is already afoot to figure out economic ways to do so. This movement is obsessed with making email exchanges as private as face-to-face conversations and keeping personal data as secure as cash hidden inside a money belt.

Here’s a second megatrend being upended:

Resource Pressures: We will be forced to more aggressively confront resource constraints. To keep volumes of major commodities (such as metals) in line with economic growth, we will need to more quickly embrace circular models: sourcing much less from virgin materials, using recycled content and remanufactured products, and generally rethinking the material economy (Winston 2019).

Except that we won’t. McAfee compares the consumption of metals for the entire US economy (not per capita) and US GDP from 1900 to 2015:

In 2015 (the most recent year for which USGS data are available) the American use of steel was down more than 15 percent from its high point in 2000. Aluminum consumption was down more than 32 percent and copper 40 percent from their peaks . . . . This dematerialization becomes even more impressive when consumption is compared to the country’s economic growth . . . . Throughout the twentieth century up to the time of Earth Day (1970), consumption of metals in America grew just about in lockstep with the overall economy. In the years since Earth Day, the economy has continued to grow pretty steadily, but the consumption of metals has reversed course and is now decreasing. We’re now getting more ‘economy’ from less metal year after year (McAfee 2019, p. 80).

How is this possible? It’s because things like aluminum beverage cans keep getting thinner and thinner, and lots of gadgets like telephones, tape recorders, flashlights, calculators, camcorders, cameras, compasses, and compact disc players— stuff with metal parts—keep vanishing inside of smart phones. Here, meaningful inventions are springing from movements to maximize resource efficiency and converge a multitude of devices onto a single digital platform all spurred on by capitalism’s price mechanism.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.