Can’t evaluate redistributive effect of individual taxes and transfers piecemeal- must look at whole distributive system.
Bruenig, People’s Policy Project, founder, 5-13 (Matt, 5-13-23, “What Makes a Consumption Tax Regressive?”, https://jacobin.com/2023/05/consumption-tax-policy-vat-progressive-regressive-redistribution-finland, Accessed 7-5-23, ED)
If we apply the spending-policy meanings of the words, we would say that cutting the VAT on electricity is very regressive: it gives five euros to the rich for every one euro it gives to the poor. But if we apply the tax-policy meanings of the words, we would say that it is very progressive: the tax savings for the poor are four times what they are for the rich after dividing by income.
Because this is a tax cut and not a tax increase, and is specifically a tax cut aimed at achieving a spending-program type goal (providing electricity subsidies), it appears to have been analyzed by at least some Finnish commentators using the spending-policy word meanings and was thus criticized as horribly regressive.
When the words are used this way, and they often are, you can wind up in a somewhat hilarious linguistic quagmire where it is “regressive” to implement a consumption tax and “regressive” to repeal it. Thus, in Finland, the 24 percent VAT is “regressive” because the poor spend more of their income on consumption than the rich. But also repealing the 24 percent VAT is “regressive” because the rich receive far more euros from such a repeal than the poor do.
If we put the imprecision of language aside — and stop putting so much weight on what label can be applied to what policy — the actual distributive stakes of a consumption tax are fairly straightforward. Because consumption taxes take more dollars from the rich than the poor, they are generally good, especially since the public programs they help finance tend to provide at least as much benefit to the poor as the rich. But insofar as other kinds of taxes — like income and wealth taxes — take even more dollars from the rich than the poor, those taxes are better than consumption taxes, holding all else equal.
Of course, ultimately, it is not really possible to analyze one piece of an overall distributive system and decide whether it is itself good or bad. What matters is whether the system as a whole achieves your overall distributive goals. Put differently: distributive justice can only really be coherently evaluated at the level of the overall system, not at the level of each particular institution in that system.
So try not to get yourself too worked up about each and every fiscal policy measure and whether, and under what meanings, that measure is progressive or regressive. Such debates are equivocal at best, irrelevant at worst.