Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Tax cuts for the rich just allow them to keep their money- it’s not redistribution.

Dorfman, UGA Economics Professor, 17 [Jeffrey, “Tax Cuts for the Wealthy are Not Income Redistribution,” Forbes, July 10, https://www.forbes.com/sites/jeffreydorfman/2017/07/10/tax-cuts-for-the-wealthy-are-not-income-redistribution/?sh=1da9a7e53297 Accessed 7/5/23 GAL]

I had a Twitter debate with Noah Smith and Matt Bruenig a few weeks ago on whether or not tax cuts for the wealthy should be considered income redistribution. I argued they should not since people were simply being allowed to keep money they had earned. Matt Bruenig (with an assist from Noah Smith) took the opposite side, claiming that since virtually all income was only earned thanks to various government-bestowed advantages and government-installed infrastructure, the original income was essentially distributed by the government. According to Noah, I lost. If so, it was not because my side of the argument was inferior, but my quickness of thought. Here is the argument I should have made.

The argument advanced by Mr. Bruenig is that by protecting property rights, investing in infrastructure, organizing public education, and similar actions, government is the true fount of virtually all wealth. Thus, the original income (or wealth) distribution was created by the government so any change in tax policy that affects the distribution is redistribution, even allowing people to keep more of their own money.

This is an important point, so it is worth more debate and an attempt by me (or others) to answer this claim. After all, the claim that tax cuts for the rich, or the repeal of Obamacare (which involves reversing tax hikes on the rich and a cancelling of benefits to the poor and middle class) are a redistribution in favor of the rich. In fact, Democrats will call pretty much every policy that in any manner allows higher earners to keep more money or makes the tax system less progressive a redistribution to the wealthy. If conservatives expect to win any policy battles and reverse the tide of free lunches for the 99% paid for by the 1%, we need to counter such accusations.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.