“Fiscal Redistribution” requires targeting on tax and/or transfer side.
Coady, IMF Fiscal Affairs Department Lead Social Spending Expert, 18
[David, 11-02-2018, International Monetary Fund, “FINANCING SOCIAL PROTECTION”, , Accessed 6-27-2023, RT]
Fiscal redistribution requires targeting; on tax and/or transfer side Optimal fiscal redistribution can be approximated with progressive income tax, consumption taxes and means-tested transfers Main challenge in developing economies is how to do means-testing of transfers with large informal economies and limited administrative capacity Categorical targeting involves trade-offs: undercoverage/leakage and fiscal cost PMTesting can improve, but issues of horizontal equity Can be (partially) overcome by PMTesting transfer levels as opposed to eligibility Choice reflects social preferences and constraints (admin, fiscal etc) Policy advice and evaluation should therefore reflect these preferences and constraints So should be country specific and could change over time.