Fiscal redistribution requires direct quantitative easing or taxation—it excludes effectual redistribution of government regulation.
Hicks, Northwestern University & Swank, Marquette University 84
[Alexander, Duane H. Marquette University; December 1984; “GOVERNMENTAL REDISTRIBUTION IN RICH CAPITALIST DEMOCRACIES”; Policy Studies Journal, Vol. 13, Issue 1; University of Kansas Libraries, ProQuest]
GOVERNMENTAL REDISTRIBUTION
Governments may affect the redistribution of income by a variety of means. They may do so fiscally; that is, by means of government expenditure and revenue flows. And they may do so normatively; that is, by means of preponderantly regulatory as opposed to monetary influences. They may do so directly; that is, by means of the net, direct, immediate (first-order) give and take of expenditure benefits and revenue burdens. They may also do so indirectly; that is, by relatively long-term and multi-stage processes, as when transfers to high-income persons employing low income household members stimulate low-income employment and earnings.
These four modes of governmental redistribution of income — fiscal and normative, direct and indirect — are cross-classified below to generate a typology of types of governmental redistribution. Four types result:
1. direct fiscal redistribution, exemplified by net, first-order shifts in income distributions resulting from government cash transfer, tax extraction, and so on;
2. indirect fiscal redistribution, exemplified by the relatively indirect, second-to-final-order impacts of (Keynesian) fiscal policy upon economic activity and, as a result, income dispersion;
3.direct normative redistribution, exemplified by the relatively direct (and intentional) impacts of regulatory policies in labor and other factor markets (e.g. open-shop or affirmative action legislation); and
4. indirect normative redistribution, exemplified by the more circuitous redistributive effects of property and contract law upon possession, exchange and, in effect, redistribution.
The typology is presented in Table 1.
Table 1
Types of Governmental Redistribution Defined by Combinations of Fiscal and Normative Policy Means and Direct and Indirect Policy Impacts