Even if Congress has the power to create protections in the contiguous zone and EEZ, they are not considered “within the United States.”
Legislative Attorney for CRS 2009 [Name Redacted, “Marine Protected Areas (MPAs): Federal Legal Authority,” April 28, RL32486, https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/20090428_RL32486_1f086a5636d3f7878cda60c01f7dd6d20810e0b6.pdf Accessed 7/15/21]
An additional issue is whether the NWRSAA is meant to apply in the territorial sea and the EEZ. The statute states:
The mission of the System is to administer a national network of lands and waters for the conservation, management, and where appropriate, restoration of the fish, wildlife, and plant resources and their habitats within the United States for the benefit of present and future generations of Americans.169
Units of the Refuge System would presently appear to be confined to areas within the territory of the United States, including the territorial sea.170 Because of the extent of the U.S. claim to ownership and sovereign jurisdiction over the territorial sea, the territorial sea could arguably be considered “within the United States.” On the other hand, it is arguable that “within the United States” does not include any area beyond the U.S. coastline. However, as multiple refuges currently contain portions of the territorial sea and as there is little to indicate that the territorial sea is not meant to be considered a part of the United States for purposes of the NWRSAA, it would seem that refuge designation within the territorial sea is permissible. Whether designation in the EEZ or contiguous zone would be permissible under current law is more questionable. Conforming to international law, the Presidential Proclamation establishing the EEZ, states that the EEZ “remains an area beyond the territory and territorial sea of the United States in which all States enjoy the high seas freedoms of navigation, overflight, the laying of submarine cables and pipelines, and other internationally lawful uses of the sea.”171 As pointed out in Natural Resources Defense Council v. United States Department of the Navy, “while the EEZ is not part of United States territory, the United States does enjoy certain ‘sovereign rights’ there, including sovereign rights ‘for the purpose of exploring, exploiting, conserving and managing natural resources.’”172 Thus, while the United States would likely be empowered to create refuge-like protections for areas within its EEZ, if Congress deemed it appropriate, it is doubtful that the areas beyond the territorial sea would qualify as “within the United States” for current NWRSAA purposes.