Federal courts have held that the EEZ is not within the United States.
Hanna, J.D. Candidate, Case Western Reserve University School of Law 14 [Matthew T., “THE EXCLUSIVE ECONOMIC ZONE: A ‘NO MAN’S LAND’ FOR UNITED STATES PATENT LAW,” Journal of Law, Technology & the Internet · Vol. 5 · 2014, https://scholarlycommons.law.case.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1065&context=jolti Accessed 7/15/21]
E. WesternGeco v. ION Geophysical A prime example of judicial deference to Congress regarding § 271 was the district court’s decision in WesternGeco v. ION Geophysical, in which WesternGeco alleged infringement of its patented marine seismic streamer technology.92 Here, ION Geophysical applied for and received a permit from the U.S. Department of the Interior to conduct a threedimensional marine seismic survey in the Chukchi Sea approximately 100 miles northwest of Wainwright, Alaska and 150 miles west of Barrow, Alaska.93 The survey would cover ocean outside of the United States’ territorial sea, but within the boundaries of the United States EEZ.94 WesternGeco alleged that the defendants violated § 271 (a), (b), (c), and (f) by “‘making, using, offering to sell, selling and/or supplying in or from the United States products and services relating to steerable streamers and/or inducing and/or contributing to such conduct.’”95 The defendants countered that WesternGeco’s complaint failed to allege any action that could be an infringement occurred or would occur within the United States.96 The court analyzed WesternGeco’s infringement claims within the framework of the traditional presumption against extraterritoriality, stating:
[A]s the EEZ is outside of the territorial United States, and Congress has limited the reach of U.S. patent law to the United States and its territories, infringing activity would not be actionable under U.S. patent law. Even though U.S. jurisdiction has been extended to the EEZ for some, but not all activities, this begs the question of whether it takes U.S. patent law—which territorially limited—along with it. Congress could extend the reach of U.S. patent law to encompass marine scientific research occurring in the EEZ, as countries such as Australia and the United Kingdom have done.97
The general holding of WesternGeco is that the U.S. EEZ is not “within the United States” for purposes of direct infringement claims under § 271(a).98 The court held that Reagan’s proclamation “incorporates the principle that the sovereign rights that the United States enjoys in its EEZ and continental shelf are ‘functional in character, limited to specific activities.’”99 This characterization supported a finding that the EEZ is not “within the United States,” but the court continued its analysis, noting that the exploration of “natural resources, both living and non-living, of the seabed and subsoil” in the EEZ could be considered conduct subject to the United States’ sovereign rights.100 The court extrapolated this proposition, entertaining the possibility that “the United States possesses a subset of resource-related sovereign rights over these activities in the EEZ and possesses the power to enforce patent law within the territorial limits of its sovereignty leads to the conclusion that U.S. patent law applies to natural resource-related activity that occurs within the EEZ.”101 The court declined to accept this argument, citing Reagan’s proclamation, customary international law, and UNCLOS for the proposition that “a country’s EEZ maintains its status as outside the territory of that country and largely maintains its status as high seas.”102 The WesternGeco court seemingly based its decision on the reasons mentioned above and the judiciary’s longstanding reluctance to extend the geographic scope of patent rights.103