A US war with China is likely and then goes nuclear—empirics prove
Butler, chief of logistics of the United States Army Civil Affairs and Psychological Operations Command, 2014
[Colonel Charles, 2014, The Fletcher Forum of World Affairs Vol. 38 No.1, 31-32, Hein Online, accessed 7-9-23, AS]
As demonstrated in the hypothetical scenario at the beginning of this paper, China's hold on rare earths may be a decisive factor in a future confrontation with the United States. The numerous weapons systems that rely on rare earths technology place the United States at a strategic disadvantage with regards to China. If a prolonged, large-scale conflict between the two nations broke out over a Taiwan Strait or South China Sea dispute, the United States may find itself squeezed to obtain sufficient supplies of rare earths to manufacture replacement parts or systems to remain engaged in the fight. Much as the lack of secure access to oil was crippling to the Germans at the end of World War II, rare earths could play a similar, pivotal role in a future conflict with China. In the air-to-air arena alone, the requirement to replace expended stockpiles of advanced air-to-air missiles could become a factor very quickly based on the number of aircraft China would be capable of employing. Japan recently learned that relying on a single resource supplier was imprudent following an incident between the Japanese Coast Guard and a Chinese fishing trawler near the Senkaku, or Diaoyu Islands.'7 In September 2010, a Japanese Coast Guard vessel attempted to stop a Chinese trawler purported to be fishing illegally in Japanese waters. During the incident, the captain of the trawler intentionally rammed the coast guard vessel. Subsequently, the Japanese Coast Guard apprehended the captain. The ensuing political spat boiled over for several weeks with the Japanese threatening to try the captain, while the Chinese suspended high-level contacts with Japan.8 During this period, an unanticipated consequence unfolded. The Chinese were scheduled to deliver several metric tons of rare earths to Japan for use in Japanese commercial industries. In what can only be seen as a direct use of its economic power in a diplomatic tussle, the Chinese withheld shipments of the rare earths during the dispute while awaiting an apology, reparations, and the release of the captain.9 China denied all accusations that it was purposefully withholding the shipments as a polit- ical bargaining tool against Japan.70 Whether China purposefully withheld the shipments or not, the lesson learned by Japan as well as outside observers was that China possesses a powerful economic instrument to employ against nations that depend on Chinese rare earths to sustain their economic livelihood.