Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Vote negative to endorse socialist revolution. Only total overthrow and replacement of capitalism can solve.

Kieran Allen 17. Associate Professor of Sociology at University Dublin College, 2017. Marx: The Alternative to Capitalism, 2nd edition, Pluto Press, p. 157-158.

In one of his early writings, Marx declared that ‘without revolution, socialism cannot be made possible’.23 In the Communist Manifesto, he and Engels were even more forthright, declaring that ‘their ends can be attained only by the forcible overthrow of all existing conditions’.24 A number of reasons were advanced for why revolution was necessary. The machinery of the state could not be used for this purpose because it had been shaped by the dominant class and their economic goals. Marx, therefore, argued that his purpose was not to ‘transfer the bureaucratic-military machine from one hand to another, but to smash it’.25 While this point was made in relation to Continental powers and Marx held open the possibility of a parliamentary transition in the US and Britain, the ‘bureaucratic- military machine’ has now grown in all countries. Unlike the capitalist class, workers need direct political power to begin the process of liberating themselves. In 1789, the bourgeoisie of France carried out a radical overthrow of the old feudal regime, but after the upheavals of 1848 in Europe they became ever more fearful of the growing class of workers below them. They are aware that in revolutions the rabble gets insolent and lays hands on things. The bourgeois gentlemen therefore seek as far as possible to make the change from absolute to bourgeois monarchy without a revolution, in an amicable fashion.26 They learnt that sometimes aristocrats could be left in political control as long as they, the capitalists, had the freedom to make money. However, a similar separation of political and economic power was not possible for workers because, unlike both the bourgeois and the aristocracy, they are an exploited class. Uprooting a system of exploitation that is embedded in the very nature of commodity exchange, therefore, required direct political force. It was also only in the process of revolution that the mass of people learnt to clarify their own interests and develop a different understanding of their society. In normal times, the majority accept the legitimacy of their rulers and at least some of their ideas. This cannot be changed simply through preaching, teaching or good example. A new consciousness cannot emerge on a mass scale by workers ‘waking up’ and then passively following the teachings of their intellectual masters or clever television presenters. Experience of class struggle is the only way in which people can learn and, as Draper put it, ‘revolution speeded up the curriculum and enriched the course’.27 In the German Ideology, Marx and Engels summed up their views on how traditional ideas were changed: Alteration ... can only take place in a practical movement, a revolution; this revolution is necessary, therefore, not only because the ruling class cannot be overthrown in any other way, but also because the class overthrowing it can only in a revolution succeed in ridding itself of all the muck of ages and become fitted to found society anew.28 Revolutions are neither accidental nor planned. They may start in the most unpredictable way, often with spontaneous mobilisations, but they arise from deeper contradictions in society. As Engels put it, ‘revolutions are not made deliberately and arbitrarily, but ... have been the necessary outcome of circumstances entirely independent of the will and leadership of particular parties and entire classes’.29 They develop from a general tumult in society that affects all social classes. Typically, the lower class does not suddenly embrace a vision of a bright new world, but rather fights for aspirations it considers just in the old world. It is only when society has reached a massive impasse that it adopts revolutionary methods to achieve these ‘moderate’ demands. The Russian Revolution of 1917 was fought, after all, over ‘land, bread and peace’.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.