Counterinterpretation—evaluate the 1AC as a discursive project, including its justifications, which matter for policy implementation and effects. Making the 1AC the focus of the debate instead of the plan is key to policymaking.
Markus Kornprobst 12. Professor, Chair of Political Science and International Relations at Vienna School of International Studies, 7-18-2012. “From Political Judgements to Public Justifications (and Vice Versa): How Communities Generate Reasons upon Which to Act,” European Journal of International Relations, vol. 20(1) p. 1-2.
Agents travel down many different roads in establishing legitimacy for policies, politics and polities. A road they very often frequent is paved with explicit communicative exchanges about good reasons upon which to act. In this study, the name used for this road is public justification. In the literature, other names such as collective legitimization (Claude, 1966; Lewis, 2005), deliberative legitimacy (Bjola, 2005) or simply legitimization (Barkin and Cronin, 1994; Hochstetler et al., 2000; Hurd, 2005; Steffek, 2003) are also frequently found.1 Public justifications are omnipresent in world politics. To give just a few examples taken from, respectively, realist, liberal, English School, constructivist and poststructuralist scholarship on the phenomenon: in order for international organizations to leave an impact, they have to give good reasons why they ought to be important in world politics (Claude, 1966; Niebuhr, 1950); civil society can leave a mark on global politics by making good reasons for change resonate with a broader state and non-state audience (Finnemore and Sikkink, 1998; Price, 1995); international order gets reproduced through the justifications actors provide (Bull, 1995; Jaeger, 2008); economic policies are deeply shaped by the justifications that actors provide for their stances (Naylor, 2011; Zangl, 2008); and whether states go to war or not has a lot to do with how domestic contestations about justifying and dejustifying the resort to war play out (Levy, 2008; McDonald, 2010). Recent literature has firmly established that justifications matter for world politics. They make it possible for a community, such as a nation, to act (Jackson, 2006; Krebs and Jackson, 2007). Addressing the question of how communities generate these justifications, this article builds on this literature. Engaging with social and political theorists dealing with this phenomenon, it seeks to make three contributions. First, I elaborate on the concept of public justification. I define the concept broadly in terms of a community’s converging on compelling reasons upon which to act. Similarly to Boltanski and Thévenot (2006), I caution that this is not to be equated with consensus ‘all the way down’.2 I contend that agreements in communities tend to be patchworks of different intensities and extents. Second, following leads provided by a heterogeneous group of scholars (Beiner, 1983; Bohman and Rehg, 1997; Elster, 1983: 88), I argue that it is political judgements — subsuming particulars under universals — that generate public justifications, and, vice versa, that these justifications shape judgements. In order to facilitate research on this link between judgements and justifications, I develop a three circuit map. The map elaborates on the linkages through which judgements generate justifications (perimeter and resonance circuits) and justifications affect judgements (resonance and structuration circuits). Third, borrowing from methodological writings in our discipline (Crawford, 2002: 119–130; George and Bennett, 2004: 67–72) and beyond (de Volo and Schatz, 2004; Marcus, 1998; Sacks, 1995), I tailor what I label a structured, focused communication analysis to inquiries into the makings of public justifications.