Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Capitalism doesn't solve economic problems, it only moves them around—the structure of the capitalist system itself renders economic crisis inevitable.

David Harvey 11. Distinguished Professor of Anthropology and Geography at the Graduate Center of the City University of New York, 9-14-2011. The Enigma of Capital and the Crises of Capitalism, p. 116-118.

There has been a tendency within the history of crisis theorising to look for one dominant explanation for the crisis-prone character of capitalism. The three big traditional camps of thought are the profit squeeze (profits fall because real wages rise), the falling rate of profit (labour-saving technological changes backfire and ‘ruinous’ competition pulls prices down), the underconsumptionist traditions (lack of effective demand and the tendency towards stagnation associated with excessive monopolisation). The separations between these schools of thought became particularly fierce in the 1970s. The very term ‘underconsumptionist’ in some circles amounted to a dirty word (it seemed to mean you were a mere Keynesian and not a ‘true’ Marxist), while fans of Rosa Luxemburg became outraged at the mean-spirited dismissal of her ideas on the part of those who placed the falling rate of profit at the centre of their theorising. In recent years, for obvious reasons, far more attention has been paid to the environmental and financial aspects of crisis formation. There is, I think, a far better way to think about crisis formation. The analysis of capital circulation pinpoints several potential limits and barriers. Money capital scarcities, labour problems, disproportionalities between sectors, natural limits, unbalanced technological and organisational changes (including competition versus monopoly), indiscipline in the labour process and lack of effective demand head up the list. Any one of these circumstances can slow down or disrupt the continuity of capital flow and so produce a crisis that results in the devaluation or loss of capital. When one limit is overcome accumulation often hits up against another somewhere else. For instance, moves made to alleviate a crisis of labour supply and to curb the political power of organised labour in the 1970s diminished the effective demand for product, which created difficulties for realisation of the surplus in the market during the 1990s. Moves to alleviate this last problem by extensions of the credit system among the working classes ultimately led to working-class over-indebtedness relative to income that in turn led to a crisis of confidence in the quality of debt instruments (as began to happen in 2006). The crisis tendencies are not resolved but merely moved around. I think it is more in keeping with Marx’s frequent invocation of the fluid and flexible character of capitalist development to recognise this perpetual repositioning of one barrier at the expense of another and so to recognise the multiple ways in which crises can form in different historical and geographical situations. It is also vital to remember that crises assume a key role in the historical geography of capitalism as the ‘irrational rationalisers’ of an inherently contradictory system. Crises are, in short, as necessary to the evolution of capitalism as money, labour power and capital itself. It takes, however, careful tracking and materialist analysis to locate the exact source or sources of the blockage in any particular place or time. A synoptic view of the current crisis would say: while the epicentre lies in the technologies and organisational forms of the credit system and the state–finance nexus, the underlying problem is excessive capitalist empowerment vis-à-vis labour and consequent wage repression, leading to problems of effective demand papered over by a credit-fuelled consumerism of excess in one part of the world and a too rapid expansion of production in new product lines in another. But we need further tools of analysis to understand the historical geography of capitalism’s evolution in all of its complexity. We must integrate the role of uneven development, both sectoral and geographical, in our analysis of crisis production. It is to this task that we now turn.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.