Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Social democratic reforms like the plan only serve to make the conditions of capitalism tolerable and suppress the revolutionary potential of the working class.

André Gorz 68. Marxist humanist philosopher and journalist, 3-17-1968. “Reform and Revolution” reproduced in Class, Party, Revolution: A Socialist Register Reader, edited by Greg Albo, Leo Panitch, and Alan Zuege, 2018. Originally published in The Socialist Register 1968, vol. 5.

The great speciality of social democratic formations is to demonstrate that all problems can be resolved or made tolerable, all material needs satisfied within the framework of the system, given time and discipline. There is no call to “rock the boat” or engage in a trial of strength; be patient, realistic, and responsible and have confidence in the leadership. Let everyone keep to his place, and the neocapitalist state will act in the best interests of all. It may well be useful for the socialist forces to show that the social democratic formations refuse to give themselves the means to carry out their program; that this program is either unrealizable, or requires such a long delay that its solution will be overtaken halfway by a change in the terms of the problem; or even that more and better can be expected and obtained if one is prepared to go further in transforming the structures. But however useful it may be, this kind of demonstration is insufficient. Essentially, it opposes promises of relative improvement by promises or more rapid or marked relative improvement. What it fails to say, and what the reformists are careful to shout at the top of their voices, is that these more rapid and more marked improvements would provoke a major crisis of the system: “You just want to break the machine, but we want to make it work better.” The socialist movement is ill-equipped to shake off this objection so long as it remains on the terrain of, general relative improvements. If it lets it be believed that there is only a difference, a difference between its policy and that of relative of degree the reformists; that basically it is seeking the same kind of objectives, but uncompromisingly and energetically, and is prepared if necessary to bring the matter to a trial of strength with capital, it is hardly likely to eat away the electoral support of social democracy and become the hegemonic force in the workers’ movement. A relative difference or a difference of degree is not, in fact, enough to make the masses prefer the perilous and arduous road of confrontation with the forces of capital to the slow but “sure” road of subordinate reformism. No one will take the risks of a political and monetary crisis or engage in a trial of strength with the bourgeoisie just to secure the building of 250,000 council houses a year rather than 200,000, an increase of 10 percent rather than 5 percent for lower paid workers, a forty-two-hour week rather than a forty-four-hour week, etc. The game is not worth the candle; if only because a more ambitious policy on the part of the socialist movement will initially provoke a brutal reaction on the part of the system, a major upheaval in the economy, and in all probability a deterioration in the material situation of the masses, at least for a short period. Social democratic and centrist propaganda is thus very telling when it asks “What’s the hurry? Why try to force the pace when a little patience and discipline will give you what you are asking for at the appropriate time and in calm and order? Is it worth risking a serious crisis to obtain in five years what could be obtained in seven or eight without great changes?” All European social democrats ask this question in one way and another, and the socialist movement can only respond by stressing that there is a basic difference between its policies and those of reformism. Not a difference of degree, delay or method of realizing the same thing as social democracy, only better and quicker. But a total difference, justifying a total risk. Only to the extent that it can convey the fact that its actions and objectives are not of the same kind as those of subordinate reformism; that what is at stake is not a greater relative or partial improvement, but an absolute and global improvement, can the socialist movement advance and establish itself as the hegemonic force in the workers’ movement. Absolute and global amelioration should not, of course, be understood to mean that the earthly paradise and the installation of socialism can be promised overnight. Rather, each partial improvement, each reform demanded, should be articulated into a general project aiming at producing a global change. The scope of this change must transcend each partial objective that illustrates one of its determined aspects: the absolute improvement at stake is the emancipation of all those who are exploited, oppressed, degraded, and crippled by capitalist relations of production in what is their social value and individual pride: their social labor. Reformists and socialists do have some wishes in common; but not for the same purposes or in the same way. For reformism, at stake in the reforming action is merely “things”—wages, public amenities, pensions, etc.—which the state is to dispense from on high to individuals maintained in their dispersion and impotent with respect to the process of production and relations of production. For the socialist movement, the workers’ sovereign power to determine for themselves the conditions of their social participation, to submit to their collective intent the content, development, and social division of their labor, is as important, if not more so, than “things.” Hence the profound difference between reformism and socialism. It is the difference between granting reforms that perpetuate the subordination of the working class in factory and society; and reforms imposed, applied, and controlled by the masses themselves, based on their capacity for self-organization and their initiative. In the last analysis, it is the difference between technical, state reforms and democratic reforms; it being understood that the latter are necessarily anticapitalist. The struggle for an authentic democracy, for any form of real participation in the management of collective interests, for any form of collective control, in particular for the workers’ control of all aspects of the process of production ... is to challenge in practice capitalism’s power of decision. An essential aspect of this struggle is the struggle of the working class for the right to manage for itself the patrimony of labor power, with all the consequences which follow from this as to the organization of labor in the factories and the autonomous management of deferred payments (social insurance, etc.).16 Thus there is necessarily a difference in method corresponding to the difference in content separating neocapitalist reforms and anticapitalist reforms. The liberating value of reforms can only manifest itself if it is already present in the mass actions aiming to establish them. At the level of method, the difference between technical reforms and democratic reforms is that separating a bureaucratically applied institutional reform and a reform imposed in the heat of collective action. From a formal point of view, any reform whatsoever—including workers’ control—may be emptied of its revolutionary significance and reabsorbed by capitalism if it is merely instituted by government fiat and administered by bureaucratic controls, i.e., reduced to a “thing.” Certain “maximalists” conclude from this that all reforms are vain as long as the capitalist state survives. They are right if they mean reforms granted from on high and institutionalized. They are wrong if they mean reforms imposed from below in the heat of struggle. A reform cannot be separated from the action which produces it. Democratic and anticapitalist reforms cannot be achieved by action that is neither the one nor the other. The emancipation of the working class can only constitute for the workers a total stake justifying a total risk if the action of struggle has already been an experiment for them in self-organization, in initiative and collective decision-making, in short, an experiment in the possibility of their own emancipation.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.