Historical “failures” of socialism are all examples of societies that attempted but never achieved true socialism.
Joel Kovel 2. Professor of Social Studies at Bard College at time of publication, 2002. The Enemy of Nature, p. 199-200.
I think I should be a rich man if given a dollar for every time someone has helpfully pointed out that it’s not good form to use the word socialism in political discourse, unless, of course, one wants to rouse the audience against an enemy People, I have been told on countless occasions, turn off at the sound of that word, with its triple association of economic failure, political repression and environmental blight. Ecosocialism, it is said, will never get to first base so long as it remains associated with the disgraced socialist tradition. It is important to deal with these objections head-on, and neither finesse them by trying to think of another word for the same thing,8 nor dismiss them by pointing to the anti-communist blight on the political intelligence. For the fact is that the nations who called themselves ‘socialist’ in the past century did display all three of those defects, and the fact also remains that as a result of the epochal collapse of the Soviet system, along with the tremendous setbacks in other societies that either called themselves socialist or had the name given to them, the morale of the socialist cause has taken one blow after another, and has pretty well declined to vanishing point over the past decade. There are a number of questions to be tackled here, chiefly whether the societies in question were actually socialist, why their failings took place, and whether a fully realized socialist society would fall into the same abyss. As for the first of these, one must unequivocally say that ‘actually existing socialism’ never passed over the threshold of restoring to the producers control over the means of production. In other words it did not live up to the stirring words of the Communist Manifesto, that the goal is for society to become ‘an association in which the free development of each is the condition for the free development of all’.9 It is essential that we not confuse the conventional definition of socialism, that it consists of public ownership of the means of production, with the true definition, that it consists of a free association of producers. The latter implies the former, no doubt, but the converse is definitely not necessarily so. A free association implies the fullest extension of democracy, with a public sphere and public ownership that is genuinely collective and in which each person makes a difference. But the word ‘public’ is tricky, and can signify another kind of alienation, namely, that of the state, or the Party, or the Leader, or whoever gets substituted for the producers and owns and/or controls the means of production in their stead. It is this latter turn of events that became the fate of socialisms past. The notion of a free association of producers is indisputably the keystone of Marx’s conception of socialism. It can be demonstrated as much as one likes from a study of Marx’s life and work —just as it can be demonstrated to have not been the case for the ‘actually existing socialisms’, chiefly the USSR and its satellites in Eastern Europe, or China, or Vietnam, North Korea, and, with varying degrees of exactitude, for the socialisms of Latin America, Cuba and Nicaragua.10 These latter all relied on some kind of alienating substitute ‘public’, generally speaking the Party—State, as the active force directing the revolution. There is as little doubt about the two sides of this proposition — of what Marx actually intended, and of what actually happened in socialism — as about the phases of the moon, and yet the error of identifying these failed experiments with Marx’s concept of socialism still persists. We need to ask why they all seemed to fail this way and whether this general failing was not in itself an indictment of the core socialist notion; and, consequently, whether there is any chance of building a socialism along the lines of a free association of producers, and with ecological rationality. Several characteristics stand out among those societies that made — and failed to realize — socialist revolutions. First of all, they were all in peripheral and dependent status among the capitalist powers. This meant that they started with two strikes against them: they were economically weak to begin with and unable to meet even the basic needs of their people; and they had to face the hostility of the stronger adversary from the moment of the inception of revolutionary power. To these may be added the third strike that put these ventures out so far as the realization of socialism is concerned: they all, each and every one, lacked democratic traditions and the institutions of civil society that fostered such traditions.