Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Russia’s revolution didn’t fail because of flaws in socialism—scarcity and impoverishment made reorganization of wealth impossible.

Terry Eagleton 11. Distinguished Professor of English Literature at Lancaster University, 2011. Why Marx Was Right, Yale University: New Haven, CT, p. 16.

Marx himself never imagined that socialism could be achieved in impoverished conditions. Such a project would require almost as bizarre a loop in time as inventing the Internet in the Middle Ages. Nor did any Marxist thinker until Stalin imagine that this was possible, including Lenin, Trotsky and the rest of the Bolshevik leadership. You cannot reorganise wealth for the benefit of all if there is precious little wealth to reorganise. You cannot abolish social classes in conditions of scarcity, since conflicts over a material surplus too meagre to meet everyone’s needs will simply revive them again. As Marx comments in The German Ideology, the result of a revolution in such conditions is that ‘‘the old filthy business’’ (or in less tasteful translation, ‘‘the same old crap’’) will simply reappear. All you will get is socialised scarcity. If you need to accumulate capital more or less from scratch, then the most effective way of doing so, however brutal, is through the profit motive. Avid self-interest is likely to pile up wealth with remarkable speed, though it is likely to amass spectacular poverty at the same time.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.