Non unique – federalism already destroyed now
Adam M. Carrington, 23. Associate professor of politics at Hillsdale College. “How the 17th Amendment Ruined Federalism.” April 8, 2023. https://www.nationalreview.com/2023/04/how-the-17th-amendment-ruined-federalism/
Importantly, whereas the Founders desired the Senate to be a body more rational, cool, and distant from popular passions, the House’s two-year terms and direct selection by the voters would reflect the people’s more knee-jerk responses. Of course, gut reactions can prove rash, dangerous, and often damaging to both public good and individual rights. The Senate’s more stoic and thoughtful poise would not result merely from its six-year term but also from the distance state legislative selection created between it and the people. State legislatures would be more likely to pick on the bases of knowledge and virtue rather than mere popularity — hence, the reason the Senate holds special powers the House doesn’t in confirming judicial nominees and ratifying treaties. Such objections to the 17th Amendment aren’t grounded in a distrust of republican government. On the contrary, they confirm the foresight of the Founders in the original constitutional structure — a wisdom that didn’t oppose government by the people but sought to channel its exercise to foster more rational and just decision-making. Right now, our country suffers from states overpowered by the national government and a Congress that’s both weak and feckless against bureaucracies, courts, and presidents alike. The 17th Amendment surely isn’t the sole culprit in the development of these woes, but it’s certainly not helping. Its anniversary is no cause for celebration.