Climate models are wrong – we can adapt
Matthew Lau, 18. Contributing writer to Canadians for Affordable Energy, citing peer reviewed studies from journal nature climate change and Journal of Climate, “Climate change data is wildly overestimated,” August 14, 2018. https://torontosun.com/opinion/columnists/guest-column-climate-change-data-is-wildly-over-estimated
A study last year by Thorsten Mauritsen and Robert Pincus in the journal Nature Climate Change and another one this year by Nicholas Lewis and Judith Curry in the Journal of Climate, produced median estimates suggesting that a doubling in atmospheric carbon dioxide would increase global temperatures by only about half of what Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) models predict.
Recently, two Heritage Foundation scholars and Canadian economist Ross McKitrick re-estimated the social cost of carbon dioxide emissions using earlier empirical estimates from Lewis and Curry, instead of relying on simulated estimates of the sensitivity of temperature to carbon dioxide concentration in the atmosphere. In one model, the social cost of carbon fell 40-50% and in another the costs dropped a staggering 80%.
In addition to future warming and its associated costs likely being over-predicted by climate models, historical warming might also be less than what most temperature records suggest. That is because some techniques for producing temperature records systematically display more warming than actually occurred.
According to Patrick J. Michaels and Ryan Maue, scientists with the Cato Institute, one of the most reliable temperature data sets is from the Japan Meteorological Office. This record also shows the least amount of warming. “The fact of the matter is,” the Cato researchers write, “that what should be the most physically realistic measure of global average surface temperature is also our coolest.”
Not only is the amount of warming often exaggerated, but climate cost estimates are often inflated by assuming that humans will not adapt to the warmer climate. This assumption makes no sense when we consider how long the warming is supposed to take and how creative our society is when it comes to solving complex problems.
Adding all this up suggests that climate change probably won’t be anywhere near as disastrous as many people imagine. This has profound policy implications – it means that the drastic and expensive tax and regulatory actions taken by governments in the name of saving the climate are increasingly difficult to justify.