States can’t solve warming
Jim Krane, 17. Wallace S. Wilson Fellow for Energy Studies at Rice University's Baker Institute. "Can America Comply with The Paris Accords Without Trump? Only If Red States Join In," Jun 7, 2017. https://www.forbes.com/sites/thebakersinstitute/2017/06/07/can-america-comply-with-the-paris-accords-without-trump-only-if-red-states-join-in/2/#2a1f8c9933c9
Hours after President Trump ejected America from the Paris climate agreement, a group of US state, local and corporate leaders vowed to pursue America’s abandoned pledge – without the help of the federal government. Heartening as it was to see Americans reject Trump’s plan to free-ride on the backs of the rest of the world, there are serious questions about any climate plan that sidelines the federal government. Can an insurgent group of CEOs, governors and mayors cut a quarter of America’s greenhouse gas emissions by 2025? The goal is a noble one, but difficult. First of all, the Trump administration is not just withdrawing from Paris. The administration is actively working at cross-purposes to the treaty’s goals. Trump and his appointees have gone out of their way to favor coal over natural gas and renewables. They’d like to see coal companies return to past dumping practices, while freeing petroleum producers from fixing methane leaks, and encouraging Detroit to walk away from fuel efficiency standards. Each of these moves takes America further from its pledge. In other words, the new United States Climate Alliance won’t be starting its anti-GHG drive from the 20-yard line. They’ll be starting deep in their own end zone. Even then, making an end-run around the White House is the easy part. The federal government has only modest influence over US energy policy. More control is devolved to statehouses, two-thirds of which sit in Republican hands. With few exceptions, Republican Party leaders publicly claim that global warming is either a hoax or caused by natural phenomena. As Fig. 1 shows, this stance is unusual outside the United States. Denial is a big problem because, when it comes to cutting emissions, the low-hanging fruit lies in Republican states, where political leaders are least likely to act. In fact, a state’s carbon intensity is a strong predictor of the way its residents voted. Each of the top 13 per capita emitting states – led by Wyoming, with 110 metric tons per person per year – went for Trump. In Wyoming, nearly 90% of voters backed the New York tycoon. Wyoming also happens to produce 40% of America’s coal that emits about 13% of US CO2. Unsurprisingly, Wyoming’s state and federal leaders are still grappling with science. Following Wyoming in the carbon intensity rankings are West Virginia, North Dakota, Louisiana and Montana. Attorneys general from two of those states, West Virginia and Louisiana, went so far as to send Trump a letter backing the Paris pullout. (So did AGs from Alabama, Arkansas, Kansas, Missouri, Nebraska, South Carolina, Texas and Wisconsin.) By contrast, Hillary Clinton won states with the lowest carbon intensity, including the bottom five: New York, Massachusetts, Connecticut, California and Maryland. The highest per capita emissions from a Hillary state flowed from New Mexico, which ranks at No. 14, with 24 metric tons/resident/year. This red-blue carbon dichotomy begs the question whether can blue states cut 25% of US emissions by themselves.