Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Fiscal redistribution historically is controlled by the states, federal intervention upsets federalism

ACIR, 81. Advisory Commission on Intergovernmental Relations. The Federal role in the federal system, the dynamics of growth. June 1981. https://library.unt.edu/gpo/ACIR/Reports/policy/A-86.pdf

Though not a grant-in-aid, the federal-state unemployment insurance (UI) system also exhibits similar deficiencies when judged from an equity standpoint, and for similar reasons. Also created by the Social Security Act of 1935, UI leaves most of the crucial policy decisions on eligibility and benefit levels to the 50 states. Hence, as in welfare, 50 separate systems exist.

Again, the political climate of the 1930s explains this outcome. While many social workers, labor intellectuals, and reformers favored a European style national system with one set of benefit standards, many businessmen and their political allies demanded flexibility, ruling out national uniformity.

Furthermore, the Supreme Court was expected to be hostile to any fully nationalized system. Hence, although responsible officials within the Roosevelt Administration-including the President himself-would have preferred a uniform program administered on a national basis, their sense of pragmatism led them to propose a strongly decentralized approach. However, rather than an open-ended grant, UI employed the device of a tax credit-previously found to be constitutional by the Supreme Court-to encourage state participation. Roosevelt's bill included no benefit standards and almost no provisions for state compliance.

In basic outline, this system has been retained until the present day. Unemployment insurance, lie the welfare programs, has proven to be extremely resistant to proposals for the standardization of benefits through federalization. Recent political rhetoric surrounding the issue of "national responsibility" for the unemployed versus "states' rights" to determine eligibility and benefit levels still sounds much like that of the New Deal period. Despite several Presidential proposals for minimum benefit standards, many analysts believe that Congressional acceptance of federalization is very unlikely. In the view of one specialist, "It's 50 years down the road before we have federal standards."67

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.