Broad interpretations of the Commerce Clause upset federalism
ACIR, 81. Advisory Commission on Intergovernmental Relations. The Federal role in the federal system, the dynamics of growth. June 1981. https://library.unt.edu/gpo/ACIR/Reports/policy/A-86.pdf
Over time, however, both the amount of federal payments and the scope of federal authority increased- initially in small, incremental steps, then in giant leaps. First Congress moved from a posture of denying federal authorities any enforcement powers to requiring the enactment of national water quality standards in the event that a state chose not to specify its own clean water criteria. In order to rationalize this shift, the federal government moved from timid reliance upon its power to tax and spend to increasingly broad interpretations of the interstate commerce clause. It institutionalized its role as a protector of the nation's waters by raising a small administrative section buried within an agency within a department to the status of an independent agency. Finally, the stated purpose of the legislation underwent a significant metamorphosis from protecting the rights and responsibilities of the states to establishing a national policy. One step behind, a similar scenario was occurring in the field of air pollution. One result of the increasing intrusiveness of federal policy was a drastic deterioration in the quality of national-state relationships. Antagonism replaced cooperation. By the mid-1970s, it could be said that: . . . whereas past policy reflected a sort of "cooperative federalism" consisting in some national but also considerable state authority, that of the present underscores "federal" and, as one might expect, is distinctly uncooperative. Pollution policy is national policy, and the states are little more than reluctant minions mandated to do the dirty work-to implement federal directives often distasteful at the local level.l16