Too much of a federal role in fiscal redistribution wrecks federalism
Howard Chernick, 07. Howard Chernick is a Professor of Economics at Hunter College in New York. “A Reconsideration of the Optimal Assignment of Redistribution Under Fiscal Federalism.” Proceedings. Annual Conference on Taxation and Minutes of the Annual Meeting of the National Tax Association, Vol. 100, 100th Annual Conference on Taxation (November 15-17, 2007), pp. 216-224.
In contrast to the standard upward assignment argument, the argument in this paper is that not only too little, but also too much centralization can be suboptimal. While there is little argument that age-based redistribution—the provision of social and medical insurance to the elderly—should be primarily a federal function, in the case of means-tested programs, too much centralization can thwart the complementarity of support by subnational governments. The greater the dispersion in fiscal capacity, need, and preferences across subnational units in a federation, the greater the importance of a balance of federal and subnational fiscal responsibility.