Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

State experimentation and independence is key to effective climate policies – federal gridlock and bureaucratic over-complications empirically deck them

Barry Rabe & Christopher Borick, 11. *Rabe is a Professor of Public Policy & Environmental Policy at the University of Michigan, Director of Center for Local, State, and Urban Policy, Nonresident Senior Fellow in Governance Studies at the Brookings Institute, Ph.D. Political Science from UChicago. *Christopher P. Borick is an Associate Professor of political science and director of the Institute of Public Opinion at Muhlenberg College, Ph.D. Public Policy Analysis from SUNY Binghamton. “American Federalism and Climate Change: Policy Options and Public Opinion,” in Climate Change and Land Policies, Lincoln Institute of Land Policy, p. 389-406, 2011, https://www.lincolninst.edu/pubs/dl/2046_1368_LP2010-ch15-American-Federalism-and-Climate-Change-Policy-Options.pdf

The inauguration of the 44th president of the United States and the beginning of the 111th Congress in early 2009 appeared to present a unique opportunity for the federal government to expand its role in climate change mitigation by drawing lessons from an expansive body of state and local policy experience generated over the past decade. This moment also opened a possibility for an intergovernmental partnership that might sort out respective functions and consider ways to either share governance responsibilities across government levels or concentrate select responsibilities within specific levels. Indeed, there is ample precedent in American government whereby state experimentation sets the stage for a more blended system, including a number of areas relevant to environmental protection. Yet by the time the 111th Congress adjourned in December 2010, it appeared highly doubtful that such a process would occur in the near future. Moreover, it seemed increasingly likely that no comprehensive federal legislation would be enacted in the next Congress, although some provisions related to alternative energy development and energy research and development may still move ahead. The American Clean Energy and Security Act, passed by a 219–212 vote in the House of Representatives in June 2009, was later withdrawn from serious consideration. Its 1,482-page text included a dizzying array of policy provisions, far short of a coherent approach to sorting out intergovernmental responsibilities or building federal law on the basis of actual state and local experience in climate policy implementation. In its place, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency continues to attempt to apply provisions of the 1990 Clean Air Act Amendments to major industrial sources of greenhouse gases (GHGs). In addition, federal agencies have begun to implement a renewable fuel mandate approved in 2007 and an agreement to increase corporate average fuel efficiency brokered in early 2009. In May 2010, the American Power Act was introduced in the Senate. Seen as the possible last chance to enact far-reaching energy legislation, it was withdrawn from review well before the November 2010 elections. As the books closed on the 111th Congress, there had been little movement on climate change policy. This development only serves to sustain the extant American governance approach to climate change, which is largely a combination of state, regional, and local initiatives. Many of these have been put into operation during the past decade, as subfederal governments have proved unexpectedly active in developing a diverse set of climate-related policies (Selin and VanDeveer 2009). In many instances, these policies were developed with the expectation of an expanded future federal role. But they will in all likelihood constitute the core of American climate policy, at least for the near future, and possibly for a good deal longer, given the considerable partisan and institutional constraints at the federal level on moving comprehensive legislation that addresses topics such as climate change, energy, and the environment. Ironically, the biggest single step taken to reduce GHG emissions in the United States during the past two decades had nothing to do with climate policy, but rather with the “great recession” of 2008–2010. It is estimated that national GHG emissions decreased by as much as 8 percent between 2005 and 2010, consistent with the experience of other nations that have faced severe economic contraction. Declines have been particularly steep in states such as Michigan that have experienced the greatest economic disruption. This underscores the challenge of developing future climate mitigation policy that does not have to rely on widespread unemployment and economic inactivity. This chapter surveys the intergovernmental landscape and the evolving national context. It begins with a brief review of policy proposals introduced in the 111th Congress, with particular attention to the intergovernmental dimensions of these initiatives. It examines the evolution of state and regional initiatives, demonstrating their broad scope and considerable overlap with many of the policies that were under consideration in the 111th Congress. This review is not intended to be encyclopedic, but rather to highlight the most salient policies and offer an early assessment of their implementation to date. The chapter provides a unique perspective on public views on the roles of various levels of government in climate policy, drawing on the 2008 and 2009 versions of the National Survey of American Public Opinion on Climate Change. These surveys confirmed the findings of other analyses that there has been a steep decline in recent years in the percentage of Americans who believe that global temperatures are increasing and that human activity is the cause. The surveys focused in particular on policy, not only exploring public support for various policy options, but also asking respondents to weigh in on whether they see climate policy as the responsibility of one or more levels of government or as something no American government should adopt. In this regard, we rely most heavily on the 2009 survey, conducted during October and November, which expanded the previous exploration of this issue and found a significant body of public support for sustaining a multilevel approach to climate change, albeit with some variance between government levels and policy tools. We believe that this constitutes the first attempt to use survey analysis to examine multilevel climate governance options in the United States in such depth and focus on the key findings later in the chapter. Lessons from the 111th Congress Between 1975 and the end of 2009, at least 479 congressional hearings on climate change were held. The majority of them examined scientific considerations, but a growing number of them considered policy options. Remarkably, however, few of the policy-focused hearings even acknowledged the existence of state, regional, and local policies, much less attempted to distill lessons from them or consider ways to devise a long-term plan for American climate governance (Rabe 2010b). Consequently, the array of proposals introduced in the 111th Congress reflects a hodgepodge of approaches to possible federal government engagement in areas where substantial subfederal involvement is already evident. A number of the proposals that included some form of a carbon cap-and-trade strategy called for full preemption of existing state and regional policies. These featured little specific discussion of how early state implementation experience might be used to guide federal policy development or how states and regions might be rewarded for early actions or demonstrable emissions reductions related to their policy steps. The American Clean Energy and Security Act introduced a compromise approach relatively late in the deliberations, putting all existing state and regional cap-and-trade programs into a five-year freeze. This meant that these subfederal programs would be halted from 2012 to 2017, assuming that the federal government had its own program operational by January 2012. The act kept open the possibility that these programs might begin to return to operation in January 2017. It was widely anticipated, however, that the Senate might move toward a total-preemption model, reflecting proposals from the 109th and 110th Congresses. Early hints of the contents of the proposed Senate bill emerging from months of deliberations led by Senators Lindsey Graham, John Kerry, and Joseph Lieberman further suggested that any cap-and-trade provision would likely be narrow in scope, but would eviscerate related state and regional programs through full preemption. Although Graham and other Senate Republicans backed away from active involvement, Kerry and Lieberman introduced a 987-page bill, the American Power Act, in May 2010. This bill proposed a wide range of strategies that might reduce GHG emissions, including a narrow cap-and-trade provision that would preempt existing subfederal programs but offer participating states some form of compensation. In turn, the legislation included a long list of assistance for a wide range of energy sources, including an expanded provision for offshore oil and gas drilling that would allow individual states to opt out in order to protect their coastal areas. The Kerry-Lieberman bill faced considerable opposition and was ultimately withdrawn from serious review. Not only does the continuing federal experience suggest considerable difficulty in enacting any climate legislation, but it also shows the absence of any coherent model for engaging states, regions, and localities in a constructive partnership across government levels. Scholars have begun to turn to this issue in recent years, considering models for allocating policy responsibility across government, although much of this work is quite new and no singular view has emerged (Engel and Saleska 2005; Posner 2010; Rabe 2008; Selin and VanDeveer 2009). Back to the States While Congress has continued to fiddle, subfederal governments have continued to move forward with policy development and implementation. This movement has accelerated in recent years, albeit under a cloud resulting from the realization by states, regions, and localities that their policies may be altered, or even eliminated, by the federal government. This has only been exacerbated by the fact that subfederal governments are facing the worst fiscal crisis in half a century, complicating their ability to sustain programs through advanced stages of implementation. This section is not intended to provide a comprehensive overview of subfederal policy, but rather to focus on two climate policies that have been widely adopted by states and have received frequent consideration in Congress.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.