Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Flexibility and innovation of states mean they solve best, fill in federal gaps, and spill up

Richard B. Stewart, 08. Professor of Law at NYU, Director of the Frank J. Guarini Center on Environmental, Energy, and Land Use Law, LL.B. from Harvard Law School. “States (and Cities) as Actors in Global Climate Regulation: Unitary vs. Plural Architecture,” Conference on Global Federalism, University of Arizona School of Law, 2/11/08, http://www.rehnquistcenter.org/StewartGlobalFederalismPaper.pdf

For the reasons discussed in Part II.A. the SNAs most likely to initiate significant independent climate regulation measures – the leader SNAs --are those that will enjoy relatively high benefits (including psychic benefits) from climate protection and face relatively low costs in reducing emissions; gain significant economic or environmental co-benefits from such measures; enjoy market/regulatory leverage in relevant product and service markets; and win market opportunities for local firms from stimulating a regulatory “race to the top.” Several of these factors may operate in give jurisdictions, and may be mutually reinforcing. Domestic and international climate regulatory initiatives by these “leader” SNAs are likely to produce climate protection benefits through a variety of mechanisms that include the following: Reducing emissions in leader SNAs. The direct effect of independent SNA regulatory initiatives will reduce emissions in the jurisdictions that adopt them.44 Cooperative agreements, whether domestic or transnational, among SNAs to adopt common regulatory measures will increase the amount of reductions achieved and ameliorate leakage. Fostering adoption of stronger climate regulation by other SNAs and the federal government. The indirect effects on regulatory policies at the national and international levels and in other SNAs may be more powerful than the direct effects. Successful SNA regulatory measures will demonstrate that it is feasible to reduce emissions at acceptable or even negative cost. They may also demonstrate that jurisdictions that initiate such measures may reap competitive advantages or other co-benefits. This demonstration effect can stimulate stronger climate regulation in other SNAs and at the federal level by helping to build public awareness of and support for their adoption, perhaps lessen industry or other opposition, and provide templates for initiative by political or governmental policy entrepreneurs. These “radiator” effects may help build a foundation for successive rounds of regulatory initiatives by leader SNAs. Even where strong federal measures are adopted, the structural political barriers discussed above will mean that they will almost inevitably be inadequate. Accordingly, the prod and stimulus of regulatory initiative by leader SNAs will continue to be needed. Stronger national regulations by the U.S. are likely to lead in turn to strengthened global regulation. Filling regulatory gaps and extending the operation of trading systems. Because of the characteristics of national and international climate political processes and of centralized regulation, gaps in federal regulation are inevitable. These will include large gaps in the coverage of trading programs. SNA measures can fill those gaps, including by extending the operation of trading through offset and credit systems, providing models and experience to inform subsequent extensions of federal regulation. Regulatory innovation and experimentation. While there may be economies of scale in research and analysis and other aspects climate regulation design and implementation, regulation at the national or international level can also involve greater difficulties in reaching agreement on new measures, mobilizing national or international bureaucracies, and the like. SNA regulation can be more nimble and often more innovative. Also, decentralized regulation allows for many more different measures and policies to be tried out. Experience with a diversity of approaches can advance knowledge about the best regulatory approaches. A single federal or global experiment, however thoughtfully designed, may turn out to be costly failure. Benchmarking and comparative learning. The adoption of different climate regulatory measures in different SNAs facilitate mutual learning by providing a foundation for horizontal mutual learning and sharing of best practices. The comparative performance of different measures in similar jurisdictions allows benchmarks to be established and to evaluate and improve regulatory approaches. Regulatory comparative advantage. Important parts of the regulatory and institutional reform initiatives needed for effective climate regulation can be better designed and implemented by SNAs. These include energy regulation, building energy efficiency transportation infrastructure and development patterns. Generic regulatory measures adopted at the national level, including emissions trading systems, must be carefully linked with functionally related local regulatory programs (e.g., building codes, state electric utility regulation) and institutional arrangements. These linkages can not be designed in a wholly top down fashion; there must be room for local initiative and learning, which can feed back iteratively with regulatory design at higher levels.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.