Federalism prevents international secessionist wars---absent the American model they are destabilizing.
Erin Ryan, 17. Assistant Professor, Lewis & Clark Law School; J.D., Harvard Law School. “Secession and Federalism in the United States: Tools for Managing Regional Conflict in a Pluralist Society.” Oregon Law Review 96: 123. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2775377.
Yet the impetus toward devolution also surfaces in conflicts between competing intra-national constituencies, cleaving along regional, cultural, ethnic, religious, linguistic, and ideological lines. In the dominant circles of international law, secession is disfavored— viewed as an extra-legal alternative that goes beyond the requirements of generally accepted principles of self-determination (at least absent gross violations, alien subjugation, international exploitation, or a colonial context).3 Nevertheless, recent calls for secession in Catalonia, Iraqi Kurdistan, Scotland, Québec, and South Sudan reveal multiple political contexts in which related questions are being raised about how best to balance competing claims for autonomy, interdependence, political voice, and exit.4
In the United States, a genuine secession movement by the Alaskan Independence Party was judicially quelled as recently as 2010, highlighting the durability of the issue even in the modern United States.5 And while calls for full secession are seldom given much credence in the American political context, calls to further devolve regulatory authority occupy hallowed positions in major American political party platforms.6 Devolution claims, often framed in terms of “States’ Rights,” have become customary on the political right—but in the wake of the 2016 Presidential Election, they are increasingly heard on the left as well.7 A group of California citizens seeking their own independence from the United States have organized a “Calexit” campaign, seeking a 2019 referendum on California’s exit from the American Union.
As secession and devolution movements threaten to destabilize federations once thought impenetrably secure—from the European Union to the United Kingdom to NATO—scholars around the globe are tapping the wisdom of the Westphalian and post-Westphalian worlds to better understand the available tools for managing regional governance conflicts.9 New scholarship exploring how different nations have managed these conflicts, some more and some less successfully, promises to broaden the perspectives of researchers, government officials, and citizens struggling to resolve sovereignty conflicts with full appreciation for the underlying principles they represent.
In support of that goal, this Article shares the American experience of devolution conflict, probing our experiments with both federalism and secession for lessons on managing the endemic tension between impulses toward autonomy and interdependence in societies composed of different regional, cultural, and ideological subcommunities. It explores secession in contexts both familiar and controversial, from the American Revolution through the Civil War, addressing secession at both the national and subnational levels.
It also considers the development of American federalism, from a model emphasizing vertical separation toward one that harnesses inevitable jurisdictional overlap to cultivate opportunities for collaborative and competitive engagement. It assesses the unique advantages of American federalism for mediating the opposing forces of political entropy, which operate to pull the component pieces of pluralist nations apart, and political gravity, which pull them together in pursuit of common goals. It considers both the successes and limits of the American model, identifying those aspects that are instructive for governance elsewhere and those that may be inapplicable abroad. Finally, it reflects on the way that federalism can act as a double-edged sword—or perhaps more accurately, a simultaneous sword and shield—providing a potential conduit for claims to secession at the same time that it functions as a safety valve to defuse the same impulses.
Beginning with a historical account of secession in the United States, Part I reviews American secession movements at both the subnational and national level, with special focus on the paradigmatic cases of the American Revolution and the American Civil War. Both examples demonstrate the deep regional tensions that can surface within a larger overall polity, reflecting the challenges of pluralist societies more generally. The southern states’ failed attempt to secede during the Civil War led to the formal disavowal of secession in the United States—leaving us to grapple with the meaning of what had already happened during the Revolutionary War, when the American colonies unilaterally separated from Great Britain.
After considering the meaning of these wrenching moments in American history, Part II turns to our preferred means of mediating regional conflict, the institution of constitutional federalism. By dividing sovereign authority between local and national levels of government, federalism creates multiple simultaneous forums for political contest, competition, and collaboration that have diffused regional tension through engaged multilevel governance. Like all systems of federalism, the U.S. model cultivates the “sweet spot” between competing claims for local autonomy and national interdependence, allocating sovereign authority among levels of government where each best advances the overall goal. The availability of nested political sites for regional expression, interjurisdictional innovation, and negotiated governance have many benefits, including fortification of the American Union against the kinds of conflicts that might otherwise lead toward fragmentation.