Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Federal UBI fails - Regional variation

Michael Tanner, 15. Tanner is a senior fellow with the Cato Institute and the author of numerous books, including The Poverty of Welfare: Helping Others in Civil Society (2003). “The Pros and Cons of a Guaranteed National Income.” CATO Institute Policy Analysis, May 12, 2015. Number 773. https://www.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/pubs/pdf/pa773.pdf

Another issue that would arise in any national level implementation of a UBI is how to address the regional variation in the cost of living. The benefit might be more than sufficient in low cost states like South Dakota, but it might not be enough in high cost states like California and New York. A recent study by the Tax Foundation looked at the purchasing power of $100 in each state, with the relative value ranging from $84.60 in Washington D.C. to $115.74 in Mississippi. Our current system addresses this disparity to some extent, although some of the variation may be due to states increasing benefit generosity for reasons other than cost of living differences. In The Work versus Welfare Trade-off 2013, I found that the benefits package from the same seven programs ranged from $25,491 in Arkansas to $49,175 in Hawaii. The impact of the UBI would vary by location, and low-income people in high cost areas could be worse off. It is not hard to imagine a scenario where people advocate for some kind of benefit adjustment based on the cost of living in the area. While this could potentially be a better design, it would again add a layer of complexity to what initially seemed like a very simple program. And, since the populations of high-cost states such as New York and California are often larger, any such adjustment could again make the program far more expensive. In short, unless we are prepared to significantly increase taxes, a pure universal basic income is unaffordable. It would also very likely lead to political pressure for a more complex and still more expensive system, one that looks less and less like a universal basic income.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.