Federal UBI fails – federal government can’t issue checks quickly and reliably
Brian Galle, 21. Professor of Law at Georgetown University. A.B., Harvard; J.D., Columbia; LL.M., Georgetown. "The American Rescue Plan and the Future of the Safety Net," Yale Law Journal Forum 131 (2021): 561-586.
Part II argues that the Checks were made necessary by our reliance on cooperative-federalism programs whose basic design makes them poorly suited to respond to recessions. While it was remarkable that the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) was able to deliver checks to millions in a relatively short period of time' (all while its workforce was operating mostly remotely), it is neither desirable nor politically sustainable to expect the federal government to implement a wholly new federal poverty-relief program in every recession.
What we need instead are recession-proof safety-net policies. Step one is figuring out what recession proofing looks like. Proponents of a universal basic income (UBI) point to the Checks as an example of the promise of simple, lightly means-tested, ordeal-less programs. Still, we need to better develop the capacity to issue checks quickly and reliably. A robust federal-option payments system can deliver the Checks, bank the unbanked, and even offer recession-period government lending.