Federal UBI fails because of funding issues, states should implement it first instead
Martha C. White, 18. Reporter & writer for NBC with 15+ years of experience as a freelancer. “Finland's experiment with giving away money shines a light on the idea of universal basic income.” NBC April 19, 2018. https://www.nbcnews.com/business/economy/finland-s-experiment-giving-away-money-shines-light-idea-universal-n869611
Other proposals have suggested raising the income tax on the wealthiest Americans, or funding a UBI system with taxes on a particular commercial activity like data collection or financial transactions — ideas that are appealing to liberals, but anathema to conservatives. “On the right, that’s a nonstarter. There’s no support for higher taxes,” Tanner said. Although this stalemate over funding could be an insurmountable impasse for policymakers seeking to implement a federal UBI, states and municipalities are putting their toes in the water with smaller-scale experiments. The San Francisco suburb of Stockton launched a pilot program this year to give $500 a month to some of its lowest-income residents, and a few Western states — California, Washington and Hawaii — have considered the idea. "It’s a broader question of what we value as a society. As a country, we’ve been prioritizing the interests of the wealthy few for many many years." Advocates are hopeful that these efforts could serve as prototypes for an eventual national model. “As we move forward, the scope of the problem will become so clear and so big, people across both sides of the aisle will recognize something has to change,” Foster said.