Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Perm do both links to the net benefit - crowds out states—decimates federalism

Alan Greenblatt, 10. News writer for npr.org and a former staff writer for Governing magazine, July/August 2010, “Is the president exploiting the states’ fiscal woes to push his policies?” http://www.ncsl.org/magazine/federalism-in-the-age-of-obama.aspx

Obama understands that he has states over a barrel financially. He has shown a great deal of interest in collaborating with states when he can, and he certainly is willing to federalize ideas that bubble up from them. But he also understands that their budget situations have diminished the ability of states to set their own courses. The federal spigot may be about to shut off, as this spring’s struggles to find extra money for Medicaid and teachers demonstrated. And the White House and a Congress riven by partisanship may leave plenty for states to do on their own. Still, this is not an administration that will support a federalism that provides more money to states to focus on their own plans and initiatives. “This is an administration that doesn’t take the states and locals as it finds them. It has an agenda,” says Paul Posner, a federalism expert at George Mason University in Virginia. “The focus will be on national goals. I can see this administration pursuing additional ways to put money down in the state and local sectors but tying it to strong national goals. It’s going to have to be a twofer.” The result might be a kind of symbiotic federalism. Washington needs states to carry out its grand visions on the ground, but the administration also fully intends to give them numerous pushes in its preferred direction. Most federal money goes out to states through set formulas. But the Obama administration is clearly interested in pursuing variations on its Race to the Top model, using competitive grants to get states to dance to its tune. If the effort at the federal level is successful, it will put a new twist on the old observation from Supreme Court Justice Louis D. Brandeis that states are the laboratories of democracy. “Rather than states being the laboratories of democracy in and of themselves,” says Howard, of Federal Funds Information for States, “some of them will become the federal government’s laboratories of democracy.”

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.