Cooperative federalism is a joke
Robert Ressetar, 03. Senior Staff member of APA, “The Yucca Mountain Nuclear Waste Repository from a Federalism Perspective,” 23 Journal of Land, Resources, & Environmental Law 219, 2003, Lexis.
To enforce the national environmental standards, most federal legislation employs what has been referred to as "cooperative federalism," in which the federal and state governments share regulatory responsibility.n21 Cooperative federalism works through a combination of financial and regulatory incentives by which the federal government encourages the states to assume regulatory responsibility for federal standards, thereby allowing a degree of local control and consideration of local situations, made more palatable to the states by means of cash subsidies. An additional incentive for state participation is the threat that the federal government will assume regulatory and enforcement authority if the state fails to fulfill its regulatory burdens. However, this implies that the states have the option of withdrawing their participation and abandoning the field to the federal government. n22 Critics claim that "cooperative federalism has proved better in theory than in practice" as either the regulated or benefited parties gain control of the federal program, or, in attempting to avoid capture, the programs become unduly expensive.n23 However, the federal government has an alternative to cooperative federalism in establishing national environmental standards. Although rarely used in the environmental arena, the federal government may use its [*222] preemptive powers under the Commerce Clause to directly regulate the use of environmentally sensitive articles of interstate commerce,n24 as it has done in the Toxic Substances Control Act. n25 Preemption as a means of environmental protection has generally been restricted to regulation of products that are nationally distributed, and the courts have preferred not to infer preemption in cases on federal pollution control laws absent a clear congressional intent to preempt. N26