No link—material improvements in the conditions of the working class are still valuable challenges to capitalism, even if they don’t result in its immediate overthrow.
Carlo Fanelli and Jeff Noonan 17. Fanelli worked in the Department of Politics and Public Administration at Ryerson University, Canada at the time of publication and Noonan is a professor in the Department of Philosophy at the University of Windsor, 4-20-2017. “Capital and Organized Labor”, Reading ‘Capital’ Today: Marx after 150 Years, edited by Ingo Schmidt and Carlo Fanelli, p. 141-142.
According to Lebowitz (2003: 27–8), Marx intended to explain the role of class struggle on the operations of capitalism in a volume on wage labour that he never wrote. We are not interested here in the Marxiological question of whether Marx ever formally abandoned the original six-volume plan for Capital. Rather, we are interested in the practical question of what the struggle for socialism looks like when we take seriously, as Marx typically did in his political work and as Lebowitz does, struggles within capitalism for a shorter working day, higher real wages, and universal access through public provision of needed life-goods. When we take those struggles seriously we discover that the struggle for socialism is neither the necessary product of the working out of the endogenous laws of capitalism nor the result of a voluntaristic, all or nothing, once and for all revolutionary movement, but a process arrayed along a continuum of better or worse lives for working people, determined by the degree of democratic control they are able to assert over the production process, the amount of time outside of alienated labour they are able to secure, the extent to which they are able to satisfy their human life-requirements, and the extent to which the private accumulation of capital is redirected towards the public provision of life-requirement satisfiers. These struggles occur within the dynamics of capitalist society, but react back against them, modifying their impact on real human lives. Lives can be better or worse for working people in capitalism depending on whether or not their struggles are successful. The laws of capitalism that Marx explains in Capital are not, in reality, forces that can exist independently of the combined actions of people (if they were, they could never be overthrown but only transform themselves into different laws or exist in perpetuity). The difference between natural laws and social laws is that the latter emerge from human action and interaction and change when those patterns of interaction change (see Gose and Paulson, this volume). As Marx himself notes in Capital, ‘the economic categories ... bear the stamp of history’ (Marx 1986: 120). While Marx himself in Capital often fails to follow out consistently the implications of this position, frequently referring to capitalist dynamics as governed by ‘iron laws’, we must interpret these claims in the philosophical context furnished by historical materialist method, which, as the quotation above reveals, is rooted in the principle that humanity is ultimately a self-determining subject (see, for example, Marx 1986: 7). As such, nothing that the exploited and alienated segments of humanity do to free themselves from alienation and exploitation is irrelevant, nor are the organizations through which those class struggles are expressed irrelevant just in case they are not directed immediately to the overthrow of capitalism. What matters, in our view, is whether the struggles aim at reducing the structural power of capital over human life, and whether they are rooted in explicit recognition of a shared life-interest in reducing that power over human beings, and not whether they are led by trade unions or revolutionary parties, or explicitly aim at revolution in the short term or only at demonstrable improvements in human life within capitalism.